5 ms·
Stallman's final interview as FSF president
- vezycash 7y ago>Stallman's post to the MIT mailing list argued, in a spectacularly INSENSITIVE fashion, that Minsky may not have been aware Giuffre had been coerced to have sex. How is this particular statement by Stallman insensitive?
- ggm 7y agoHe should have argued as vociferously for the alternative: he may have been aware. He should have argued for the girls perspective. The insensitivity was to ignore the girl,and her rights, and her status,in discussing Minsky's
- alt_f4 7y agoI believe Minsky was his (now dead) friend. If something like this comes up for a good, deceased friend of yours, will you pick the side of an unknown to you girl over the person you knew and care about? I'm not saying that's the correct side, but it's a human, emotional thing, rather than rational.
- lliamander 7y agoI've only read some of his comments after the fact. I don't think he was taking sides against the young women, as much as just speaking up for a friend.
- alt_f4 7y agoI agree, but I don't know how to phrase it better.
- lliamander 7y agoNo worries. For what it's worth, that's what I assumed you meant. I was more or less attempting to rephrase it in my own words. In a world where one's written words can be so twisted beyond their original intent, it's good to reaffirm an assumption of good faith.
- PavlovsCat 7y agoI wouldn't come to a conclusion before even considering what situations would be plausible for the girl to be in. In the case of a 17 year old and a 73 year old, the main responsibility rests with the adult, just based on the respective age and positions of power. I wouldn't make an exception for friend nor foe, but if I had a friend who did that, I wouln't any longer consider him a friend, and there is nothing about the girl, short of her raping him, that could change that. "Friend" isn't just some flag that gets set by cosmic rays and then stays that way forever, that would make it meaningless to me, not more noble.. blind loyalty isn't loyalty, just blindness. I say this as someone who did cast of friends, which was painful to me, even though it was for totally trivial and harmless, outright edifying reasons in comparison.
- alt_f4 7y ago> "Friend" isn't just some flag that gets set by cosmic rays and then stays that way forever. Agreed. It's more of a collection of experiences and knowledge of character. If I've known you for 20 years and known you to be a good person, if I hear something like this I'm more likely to believe this is some sort of a mistake, as it is completely out of character. One way to rationalize it would be to believe that you were misinformed, rather than me being a poor judge of character for all of these years. Again, not saying it's what happened - i dont know. But it's just human nature to react like that. It's not really human nature to consider the social media and print media applications before writing an opinion.
- PavlovsCat 7y agoYou're essentially just describing what you're not saying, and "some sort of mistake" is much too generic for me. While I personally wouldn't feel much better about a friend having sex with someone a third their age even if that person is an adult, it's impossible to have sex with a minor by accident, unless they have fake ID. Not even asking for it means not caring, no ifs and buts. "Human nature" is also too generic, the question was, how would you react. I answered that question, and have the former friends I showed the door to prove it. It's clearly within "human nature" to react like that, too.
- lliamander 7y agoI assume that he would agree that the girl was victimized (as would I, obviously). Why argue vociferously for a position that everyone in the discussion already agrees with?
- partialrecall 7y agoPragmatically: So as to stave off comments such as the one you responded to.
- lliamander 7y agoThat is probably what you or I would do, yes. My point was that perhaps such disclaimers should not always be as necessary as they are.
- partialrecall 7y agoFully agreed.
- toomim 7y agoI think the statement in question is "The most plausible scenario is that she presented herself to him as entirely willing." This statement isn't sensitive to the anger that people feel towards Epstein and thus Minsky, and the fact that Stallman has said it in this angry environment has caused quite a spectacle. So in that sense, I think one might call it "spectacularly insensitive." On the other hand, I think that was the point. And I don't think that all public intellectuals should be required to be sensitive to the angry mobs at all times. I'd like someone to stand up to the mob, from time to time.
- lliamander 7y agoRead: "most plausible in light of what I know personally about the character of the accused". Of course, Stallman could just be a poor judge of character and did not pick up on Minsky's flaws. EDIT: to be clear, the italicized part is what I infer Stallman's intent was.
- kelnos 7y agoBecause it's besides the point. It's a distraction from the actual topic at hand. It's also naive. I mean... powerful billionaire brings you to his private island and presents to you a beautiful young woman who wants to have sex with you, a 70-something man. That sounds like the "plot" of a really bad porno. You'd have to be obnoxiously naive to believe the woman wasn't being coerced in some way.
- alt_f4 7y agoA lot of women enjoy sex. Some enjoy BDSM, some enjoy tentacle porn, some enjoy sex with older men and so on. If she seemed friendly, interested and didn't mention anything about this being against her will, how would he know she is being forced? Should we just assume a younger woman can never be interested in an old guy? As a rather extreme example, Hugh Hefner's 3rd wife was early 20s when she married him and he was in his mid 80s. Should we assume he coerced her too?
- lliamander 7y ago> I mean... powerful billionaire brings you to his private island and presents to you a beautiful young woman who wants to have sex with you Which means powerful billionaire wants to own you, and you should gtfo while you can. > You'd have to be obnoxiously naive... Well, some people probably are. > ..to believe the woman wasn't being coerced in some way. or believe that she was willingly paid? Idk, I think I'd be creeped out way before it came to that, but who knows.
- berberous 7y agoAssuming the allegations that they had sex are true, I think the most likely scenario, and the one that Minsky believed, was that she was a completely willing paid escort. It's only in hindsight that you think it must have been obvious she was coerced in some way. Why would he assume a billionaire had not simply used some of his money to pay for escorts? Isn't that more logical, without knowing what you know today about Epstein?
- romwell 7y ago"Huh, this billionaire bought me a child prostitute. Neat." ...I don't think it makes it any better.
- DATACOMMANDER 7y agoIt wasn’t, and it’s absurd that people still insist on calling it a sexual assault. Stallman’s logic was spot-on.
- romwell 7y ago>>Minsky may not have been aware Giuffre had been coerced to have sex. >How is this particular statement by Stallman insensitive? It's insensitive to the fact that if you are a very old, famous man, who is taken by another old, rich man to a private island, where a seemingly willing 17-year-old girl offers sex - - then the right thing to do is to politely decline the offer, because anyone with a half brain cell, a world-famous scientist more so, can figure out what that is about. The statement is insensitive regardless of the allegations. It shows that RMS, alas, doesn't think that something that we today can't accept is wrong at all. Does it make him unworthy of being the president of the FSF? I don't know; he has been right about the tech, I think. I just wish he abstained from commenting on social matters that don't have anything to do with FSF concerns.
- evilmoo 7y agoThat’s a hell of a travel rider.
- emptybits 7y agoI enjoyed that rabbit hole, also. > I am willing to stay in a hotel if there is no other way. ... My distaste for a hotel is less if it does not know my name, but staying in a house with people is normally more enjoyable than staying alone.
- 13hours 7y ago>If you can find a host for me that has a friendly parrot, I will be very very glad. If you can find someone who has a friendly parrot I can visit with, that will be nice too.
- shultays 7y agoHe was our guest for a conference and stayed for a couple days. He ia an interesting person indeed. Preferred to stay at someone's house instead of a hotel. If that person has a parrot that would be a plus. And some other crazy stuff. He has a 3 page document that explains what he likea and what not (i am not saying it is weird or he is asking for too much, for a frequent traveller such as him i think it is perfectly ok) Funny story. He "stole"/borroe my phone. He didnt have a phone so we lended him one. My phone was a dumb phone and we guessed that would be better. After the conference, he took my phone to another conference that was in our country. I got it back though
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 13hours 7y agoI'm actually baffled that someone so tone deaf about so many things was able to create such a success.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- toomim 7y agoIt isn't accurate to presume that someone is deaf to a tone, just because they make a statement that doesn't acknowledge the tone. Let's not make the mistake of calling Stallman unintelligent or deaf. He simply chooses to direct his attention to other tones.
- 13hours 7y agoI looked up a definition of "tone deaf" to see if I misunderstood in my interpretation of the term and how I used it above. >having or showing an obtuse insensitivity or lack of perception particularly in matters of public sentiment, opinion, or taste Having read that I stand by what I said. In my opinion he has shown "an obtuse insensitivity or lack of perception of public sentiment" on more than one occasion. The Minsky message being a very good example. Whether you agree with the sentiment or not is seperate from clearly being obtusely insensitive about the public sentiment I think.
- blaser-waffle 7y agoNo one is questioning his book smarts or ability to perceive auditory sounds. But, like, learn how to read the room, man. He waded into the crazy internet morass that is sexual assault and Epstein, and didn't realize that quotes like the one below might trigger a response. That is either hopelessly naive, or absolutely "tone deaf" -- these have been over-the-top, hyper-sensitive topics for weeks. Maybe he's just so used to staking odd or controversial positions and didn't see this as any different, I don't know. But the optics are terrible. > "The most plausible scenario is that she presented herself to him as entirely willing," Stallman wrote in his post last Wednesday. "Assuming she was being coerced by Epstein, he would have had every reason to tell her to conceal that from most of his associates. I’ve concluded from various examples of accusation inflation that it is absolutely wrong to use the term 'sexual assault' in an accusation."
- caspervonb 7y agoMeanwhile, blue checks with substantial mob following on Twitter are calling him a "literal pedophile rapist".
- knolax 7y agoJust saw a tweet that claims he "LOVES RAPE".
- craigsmansion 7y agoYes, the actually unpalatable elements of the FLOSS community are crawling out of the woodworks now. I would have never expected the Software Freedom Conservancy and the EFF to be amongst them though. Poor Richard, having his life's work usurped by the ankle biters and the self-aggrandising.
- DanBC 7y agoMost people don't need to be told that child abuse is bad. Stallman used to think child abuse wasn't harmful. He only changed his mind after survivors of abuse spoke to him. Some will claim this is evidence of his scepticism but really it's evidence of lazy thinking. He could have done a tiny bit of reading before saying that child abuse isn't harmful, but he chose not to do so.
- leereeves 7y agoAlmost all societies used to believe (and some still do) that what we now call child abuse was ok. People who experienced it themselves would go on to do it to others. Getting past that was a thought evolution that took hundreds of years, not "a tiny bit of reading". Stallman dared to question the dominant belief in the US today, and needed more evidence before accepting that belief. With sufficient investigation (hardly "lazy thinking") he came to agree with it, but that's not enough for the social media mobs. His experience shows that one must not only accept the dominant belief, one must accept it immediately and without question, because a moment of heresy will never be forgiven or forgotten.
- BlackRing 7y agoThe medium article that was parroted by other sites was a hit piece that lied. And of course the people reading it believed every word without a shred of doubt, and other outlets republishing it failed journalistic integrity spectacularly. Congratulations, to all those who fell for it. https://old.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/d5a4dz/_/f0l50w4/?context=2 https://old.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/d5a4dz/_/f0l50w4/?co...
- mothsonasloth 7y agoAbout time if you ask me. RMS is brilliant but also completely unpalatable to people outside the world of GNU. Time for someone who is a bit more accessible and savvy to take the FSF cause onwards. The question though would be, will the FSF mission change or it's cause be diluted without RMS at the helm?
- lliamander 7y ago> RMS is brilliant but also completely unpalatable to people outside the world of GNU. He just sacrificed his job and legacy to defend the honor of a friend. What kind of person do you want leading the FSF, a mealy-mouthed politician?
- stephenr 7y ago> He just sacrificed his job and legacy to defend the honor of a friend. He resigned after claiming that a victim of child sex trafficking, was "a member of (the trafficker's) Harem" and "entirely willing". Defending his dead friends honour might be to raise the question of whether it was in fact his friend who was involved. He essentially gave the "but she wanted it" defence, for a dead man, who is accused of raping a child whom he had "borrowed" from another dead man, who is also accused of raping children. > What kind of person do you want leading the FSF, a mealy-mouthed politician? Most people would probably just be happy with someone who doesn't say the following about prostitution, adultery, necrophilia, bestiality, possession of child pornography, and even incest and pedophilia (and I quote): > All of these acts should be legal as long as no one is coerced. They are illegal only because of prejudice and narrowmindedness.
- nahalay 7y ago"The most plausible scenario is that she presented herself to him as entirely willing," (Meaning not willing, emphasis on presented .. as) How do you sleep at night knowing you are smearing other people with obvious falsehoods?
- partialrecall 7y ago
- zecg 7y ago"I was involuntarily self-promoted into management."
- microtherion 7y ago> I never believed that Microsoft was the great Satan. I suspect that the great Satan for RMS was mostly Apple. I don’t think he and his organizations have ever advocated a boycott of Microsoft, while they have called for boycotts of both macOS and iOS at times — and notably at a time when MS owned something like 90% of the OS market, they advocated for a boycott of more or less their last PC OS competitor. I never quite understood that focus. Maybe it was because Stallman thought that Apple, with its hippie roots, was the bigger disappointment for not aligning themselves with his values.
- izacus 7y agoOr maybe it's because Apples values are significantly more hostile to FSF than Microsofts? Apples flagship devices are completely forbidden from running anything not approved by the corporation and their AppStore is completely incompatible with GPL software. It fundamentally goes against everything FSF stands for: being able to run any kind of software and modify it on your own machine. In a world of Apple, FSF is forbidden from existing by policy and hardware lockouts. Microsoft never came close to this kind of lockdown. And Apple was always like that - even for Apple Lisa they developed a scheme where a floppy would be permanently bound to a single machine on first use practically forbidding resale. There are really not many large software companies that would be more hostile to FSF core values than Apple.
- microtherion 7y agoiOS development is not really compatible with the GPL; both the FSF and Apple agree on that. But there was nothing in macOS that was incompatible with the GPL, and yet the FSF for a decade prohibited its maintainers from accepting macOS specific patches (So much for “freedom”). To Stallman, Apple’s “Look & Feel” lawsuit was an unforgivable transgression, but Microsoft’s various tactics to muscle out competitors were never a cause for concern.
- segfaultbuserr 7y ago> Maybe it was because Stallman thought that Apple, with its hippie roots, was the bigger disappointment for not aligning themselves with his values. I also believe this is the reason. Recall RMS's commentary when Steve Jobs passed away, he basically said: nobody should die, but I'm glad to see him leaving Apple, as he has built a cool prison of Apple in his life. It even triggered some strong actions within the community, "it's time to fork the FSF", from members who see and respect Steve Jobs as an important hacker in computer history. But to RMS, he has been excommunicated from the hacker community for what he has done, regardless of his early life.
- rswail 7y agoJohn Lennon was a misogynist but wrote world changing music. Churchill was a racist that (arguably) saved his nation from invasion. Stallman is a Marxist ("from each according to his abilities, to each according to his needs") when it comes to how the power of computing is used and distributed and arguably the GPL and Linus's choice to use it for Linux have had world changing effects. But Stallman is a man that also has no clue about how to deal with people in general or in tolerating other views. His defence of Minsky's behavior is unacceptable as the head of the FSF and damaging to CSAIL/MIT (as is the relationship of MIT to Epstein in general). It is unfortunate for him that his defence of Minsky has had this effect on his career. However, the impact of the result of that defence on the institutions he represented is much more important to resolve. Geniuses in one field are not knowledgable in others.
- ijiiijji1 7y agoUnless they are just mythological, all people are fallible, inconsistent human beings who put on their pants one leg at a time. There is no magic.
- rimliu 7y agoIt is interesting how you presented communist slogan as a marxist.
- stephenr 7y ago> Geniuses in one field are not knowledgable in others. What "knowledge" are you suggesting is required, that RMS does not posses, to understand that fucking kids is not OK? Is this like when a sports "star" rapes someone, and then the team says they'll have "training". What does this training look like? "Lesson 1. DON'T RAPE PEOPLE. Class dismissed."
- jacquesm 7y agoI've made this point elsewhere, but it is Minsky's alleged behavior and Stallman did Minsky a large amount of harm by defending him as though it had definitely happened. See also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20992876 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20992876
- gwd 7y agoThis is a pretty interesting comment in hindsight: " But I believe in judging each thing that a company does separately. So if a company is doing this thing, which is wrong and unjust, and this thing, which is helpful, I'd rather not add them up. If these two activities are separable in practice, in other words, if it's possible to look at each one, individually, and distinguish it from the other, if they're not tied up with each other, so much that that's a nonsensical thing to do, then I do that. Because that way, I can disapprove of whatever is bad and approve of whatever is good. That's more useful, just adding it up to get one total for a given company." Treating people that way, and expecting to be treated that way, is part of the reason he's had to step down.
- reacweb 7y agorms writes and talks a lot. This gives many opportunities for his opponents to find ways to attack him. The main point of rms is freedom. Freedom is a right than can sometimes benefit to evil people. Defending freedom does not mean we defend evil people. I don't see anything reprehensible in the comments of rms, just opportunities for his opponents to use this fallacy.