2 ms·
I'm beginning to lean toward the camp of Rust replacing Python, too--and I've been using Python since 1996-ish. My primary limitation in Rust is the state of t
by bsder 7y ago
I'm beginning to lean toward the camp of Rust replacing Python, too--and I've been using Python since 1996-ish. My primary limitation in Rust is the state of the libraries--Python libraries and frameworks are simply a LOT more stable in general.
The first question is "What does Python do better than Rust?" Libraries/frameworks is the big one--there is no excellent Django-equivalent or Jupyter notebook-equivalent, for example (maybe there never will be by virtue of the language differences, but it is what it is). Python helper scripts generally ship in .py form so you can fix bugs in crappy Python scripts (if people start shipping Rust auxiliary scripts that's going to be a step backwards). Verbosity--okay, I'll concede that if I want things to be mostly GC, I'm writing a lot of extra wording in Rust.
And when I reverse the question: "What does Rust do better than Python?" The answer is a whole lot. Strong typing is a big one--because of Rust doing okay type inference I don't wind up with types repeated very often--it feels more like Python. Performance, sure, but I rarely care. Tooling seems to be a bit better--and Rust seems to be targeting to be a first class citizen on Windows. And, of course, concurrency--Python should have just sucked it up, taken the performance hit in 3.0 to remove the GIL and then optimized performance back over 7 versions (Good concurrency is becoming a standard in languages--I suspect Python is eventually going to concede this or start losing mindshare--and the pain would have been best suffered back at 3.0).
Yes, there are issues. If you have a doubly-linked anything in Rust, you're about to have a bad time (or not, if you REALLY need double-linkage--it's time to quit being pedantic, to break out "unsafe" and to encapsulate things). If you're writing a library, your lifetime annotations look like 300 baud line noise.
I really learn a new language about every 10 years or so--I have to feel a significant upside without a lot of downside in order to move (my last big change was Perl->Python in about 1996--my history of languages that I knew cold is assembly->C(with a C++ excursion for a bit--I got better)->Perl->Python). At this point, for one-off things that I'm writing a quick 100 lines, I'm starting to reach for Rust more and more and Python less and less.