5 ms·
Shades of Tocqueville[1] who wrote about the dangers of anti-intellectualism in America even earlier. For instance, Kaledin says, to an extent greater than is
by mindcrime 7y ago
Shades of Tocqueville[1] who wrote about the dangers of anti-intellectualism in America even earlier.
For instance, Kaledin says, to an extent greater than is usually emphasized, Tocqueville thought “populism would gradually lead to an anti-intellectual culture and to mediocrity in political leadership.”
I don't think you could come up with a better summary than "mediocrity in political leadership" to describe the current climate.
[1]: http://news.mit.edu/2011/tocqueville-1129 http://news.mit.edu/2011/tocqueville-1129
- SoylentOrange 7y agoI’m not sure this is accurate, if attempting to compare US political figures with those of other countries. I don’t know if there is hard data on this, but I would bet the US Congress has proportionally just as many graduates of top universities as any other legislative body in the world. If anyone wants to crunch the numbers, I would be excited to see the percentage of US Congresspeople with serious educational attainments vs Japanese, French, German, Canadian, or any other similar body.
- einpoklum 7y agoGraduating university does not an intellectual make.
- indecisive_user 7y agoSure, at the individual level graduating from a top tier university or with a phd doesn't mean you're an "intellectual". But from a population standpoint, the two are certainly correlated. The number of congress people should be large enough to assume population level statistics unless there's some serious biases _against_ intellectuals running for or winning political races.
- shsjdhsi 7y agoI disagree. After a certain amount of the pop. gets certain degrees, it’s just a cheapening of the degree. For example, despite having an eng PhD from a top 10 (5?) university in the US, I know I wouldn’t have been awarded one from a top 100 50 years ago. The standards were higher And you don’t cheapen what you treasure.
- einpoklum 7y ago> The number of congress people should be large enough to assume population level statistics It's not a uniform sample. In fact, it's not even sampling from the same population - it's a set of samples of size 1...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- SoylentOrange 7y agoYou are 100% right. However I was trying to respond to the parent commenter’s point about mediocrity. I was trying to craft a simple metric which would speak to mediocrity. It’s an imperfect metric for sure.
- bobthechef 7y agoWhat a lazy comment and a perfect demonstration of the aforementioned anti-intellectualism.
- human20190310 7y agoIs mediocrity in political leadership so bad? History's greatest catastrophes were undertaken by overachievers.
- lambdasquirrel 7y agoSure, but that’s probably a variance thing. The overachieving can be a multiplier unto itself. Do you notice it though, when you have a Brezhnev, or a Qin Er Shi, or a Louis XVI? Napoleon was so much cooler than Czar Nicolas II. We don’t remember those other folks as much, and sometimes the effect of their rule isn’t immediately or decisively felt.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't take HN threads into political flamewar. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- mindcrime 7y agoYour comment is irrelevant, since I did nothing of the sort.
- dang 7y agoThis sentence seemed like an obvious partisan shot: > I don't think you could come up with a better summary than "mediocrity in political leadership" to describe the current climate. But when I re-read it, it seems more likely to have been a "pox on all their houses" sort of comment. If that's what you meant, I'm sorry for misreading you.
- mindcrime 7y agoNo worries. I really do mean that, in general, our political climate seems dysfunctional in a way that I personally think reflects exactly what Tocqueville was talking about. I wasn't calling out any specific person or party or anything. That said, "a pox on all their houses" does come pretty close to reflecting my views on many political issues. :-)