4 ms·
As written, that seems awfully broad. For example, if a person who owns a farm in Merced county were elected to the legislature and then were to support any leg
by tzs 7y ago
As written, that seems awfully broad. For example, if a person who owns a farm in Merced county were elected to the legislature and then were to support any legislation that benefits farmers in general they would have run afoul of that law.
I assume that it is interpreted more narrowly than that. So, say, a farmer in the legislator trying to get, for example, a new aqueduct project approved to lower water costs for farmers in a large region would be OK even if they themselves would benefit from lower water costs, but that same legislator trying to get the state to pick their spouse's excavating company when awarding the construction contracts for the project would not be OK.
- toast0 7y agoSection 87102.5 goes on to say: > (a) The remedies provided in Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 83100) shall apply to any Member of the Legislature who makes, participates in making, or in any way attempts to use his or her official position to influence any of the following governmental decisions in which he or she knows or has reason to know that he or she has a financial interest: ... > (3) Introduction as a lead author of any legislation that the member knows or has reason to know is nongeneral legislation. > (4) Any vote in a legislative committee or subcommittee on what the member knows or has reason to know is nongeneral legislation. > (5) Any rollcall vote on the Senate or Assembly floor on an item which the member knows is nongeneral legislation. Non general legislation is defined [2] as: > (a) “Nongeneral legislation” means legislation as to which both of the following apply: > (1) It is reasonably foreseeable that the legislation will have direct and significant financial impact on one or more identifiable persons, or one or more identifiable pieces of real property. > (2) It is not reasonably foreseeable that the legislation will have a similar impact on the public generally or on a significant segment of the public. > (b) For purposes of this section and Section 87102.5, all of the following apply: > (1) “Legislation” means a bill, resolution, or constitutional amendment. > (2) “Public generally” includes an industry, trade, or profession. > (3) Any recognized subgroup or specialty of the industry, trade, or profession constitutes a significant segment of the public. > (4) A legislative district, county, city, or special district constitutes a significant segment of the public. > (5) More than a small number of persons or pieces of real property is a significant segment of the public. > (6) Legislation, administrative action, or other governmental action impacts in a similar manner all members of the public, or all members of a significant segment of the public, on which it has a direct financial effect, whether or not the financial effect on individual members of the public or the significant segment of the public is the same as the impact on the other members of the public or the significant segment of the public. So --- it's not quite as broad as the earlier quote. But, I guess the question becomes is companies that like to retain more information than they need to do their job a recognized subgroup of the industry? The point of the conflict of interest rules, though, is to make it crystal clear that any sort of appearance of conflict is to be avoided, which includes conflicts by virtue of marriage. Based on the definition of nongeneral legislation, I'm guessing this is probably fine (but is worth a look by the commission), but if it is OK, the legislator should say as much, and not claim independence from the spouse -- because the law does not allow for such independence. [1] https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?sectionNum=87102.5.&lawCode=GOV https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySectio... [2] https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=GOV§ionNum=87102.6 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySectio....
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>As written, that seems awfully broad That's a feature not a bug. It provides cover when "good people" do it and an opportunity to use the courts to get your way when "bad people" do it.
- noselasd 7y agoI don't see any problem with that scenario at all. There's plenty of politicians, and we're better off when the ones that have an interrest or benefits just backs out and don't participate in that particular cause.