3 ms·
I think the problem is that people just aren't willing to make sacrifices. Just look at how these threads go, someone will suggest that maybe we should stop fly
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago
I think the problem is that people just aren't willing to make sacrifices. Just look at how these threads go, someone will suggest that maybe we should stop flying around the globe for fun, stop demanding access to fresh fruit year round, eat less meat, not upgrade our iPhone every 6 months, etc. and what do people do? They say, "oh, but I'm just a drop in the bucket". Everyone is very much for someone else making sacrifices, as long as it isn't them. And that's why we're doomed. Hopefully, the next go at global civilization can learn from our mistakes.
- philipkglass 7y agoPeople calling for government action are willing to make collective sacrifices. Making individual sacrifices will not change the trends that need changing. That's realism, not hypocrisy. You can't push adulterated foods out of the marketplace by telling individual consumers to make wise choices. You need something like the Pure Food and Drug Act. You can't push water-polluting laundry detergents out of the marketplace by telling individual consumers to make wise choices. You need something like the Clean Water Act. Telling Los Angelenos agitating for clean air, circa 1967, that they should buy their own cleaner cars (or find ways to avoid driving altogether) before supporting the government California Air Resources Board would likewise have been futile. They needed regulation, not more personal virtue. Positive collective action is required to solve collective action problems. I already went vegetarian and drive less than most Americans. I've never mentioned my personal behavior in climate discussions here before because it's beside the point. I keep upvoting posts that propose carbon taxes and tariffs (or equivalent statutory phase-out requirements) because those are the things that will make a difference.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago> People calling for government action are willing to make collective sacrifices. Making individual sacrifices will not change the trends that need changing. That's realism, not hypocrisy Yeah, no rain drop believes it is responsible for the flood.
- nothrabannosir 7y agoThat’s because it isn’t. If you want to stop a flood, don’t target individual raindrops, target the whole storm.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoThe drops are the storm. Ok, we're stretching the analogy now, but if people are unwilling to make sacrifices for themselves, why would they be willing to vote for policies that negatively impact them? And you know what? From the election results what people base their political decision making on it seems that they won't. If you actually, truly give a damn instead of just using it a some kind of virtue signaling then you should be willing to make sacrifices. Demonstrate that you care instead of just talking.
- anigbrowl 7y agoThat's not so. Many people are willing to and already make sacrifices but are also fully aware of the free rider problem in that people who pollute historically try to dump the blame on consumers. If they want the status of being captains of industry or business leaders, but they don't come through on matters of serious public concern where they can make a difference, it's not wrong for people point out their hypocrisy. Why is it the responsibility of the least powerful people to sacrifice first before those who profit from the status quo inconvenience themselves?
- nothrabannosir 7y agoPeople aren't willing to make individual sacrifices to solve a tragedy of the commons, and with good reason: it doesn't actually solve the problem. This is not specific to CO2, it's part of the definition of tragedy of the commons. People are, however, far more receptive to collective sacrifices, such as a carbon tax, or its more PC name "carbon price". If your lake is being overfished, you can stop fishing all you want, it won't change a thing. You need quotas or a tax. It's a tragedy of the commons and we need to move together on this.