4 ms·
This is what your customers think of asking for their email password
- shawndrost 18y agoThis is what Jeff Atwood thinks of you asking for his email password. My personal impression is that most people don't give a shit.
- icky 18y agoIt's true. If someone asked me for Jeff Atwood's email password, I wouldn't mind at all.
- paul 18y agoThis isn't as big of a deal as people are making it out to be. The fact is that I DO give out keys to my house to a number of people that I trust. Likewise, I've used this import feature on a few websites that I trust, such as Facebook, and would be willing to do the same on Yelp if I used that. The notion that it's somehow unethical is just silly. Of course people should be hesitant to give their passwords to random web sites, but then again they should also be hesitant to give they address book out to random websites (I don't want spam just because you signed up for some scammy site). The people most likely to fall for scams probably use the same password everywhere, btw.
- raganwald 18y ago"I DO give out keys to my house to a number of people that I trust." Your house keys are less dangerous than your email password. As jeff points out, with your email password someone can probably take control of all of your web credentials. It's as if you have them your house keys, and then they use those to take control of your snail mail, and then they apply for new credit cards in your name, and order a new set of car keys, and so on. And of course, we are not talking about giving your house keys to a friend staying with you. We are talking about giving your house keys to the bartender because he says he can help you invite all your friends to have a drink with you.
- paul 18y agoWith my house key, they can get to my email, so email permissions are narrower than house permissions. Someone with access to my house can definitely cause more trouble than someone who only has access to my email. It's not just friends either btw, I also give house keys to the cleaners, etc. If your email is so super secret, then you probably shouldn't trust Yahoo or Microsoft with it either, btw. I'm not saying that there aren't security issues, but you need some perspective here. Facebook is just as secure as Yahoo, so letting them use your Yahoo password really isn't that big of a deal.
- raganwald 18y ago"Your email account is a de-facto master password for your online identity. Most -- if not all -- of your online accounts are secured through your email. Remember all those "forgot password" and "forgot account" links? Guess where they ultimately resolve to? If someone controls your email account, they have nearly unlimited access to every online identity you own across every website you visit." ...and... "how can I take your privacy policies seriously if you aren't willing to treat your competitors' login credentials with the very same respect that you treat your own?" Solid gold.
- raganwald 18y agoAlternative ways to scrape your email addresses without asking for your login credentials (from a comment on the OP): Google Contacts API: http://code.google.com/apis/contacts/ http://code.google.com/apis/contacts/ Yahoo! Contact API: http://developer.yahoo.com/addressbook/ http://developer.yahoo.com/addressbook/ Windows Live Contact API: http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/bb463989.aspx http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/bb463989.aspx
- breck 18y agoAwesome. I was looking for this in a HN post a couple days ago.
- imp 18y agoI love the comparison between the urls for each company. Google and Yahoo have nice clean ones while Microsoft isn't even trying.
- andr 18y agoProbably because Microsoft has enormous amounts of documentation online, organized in a single library, while Google and Yahoo don't...
- simonw 18y agoNope, it's because Microsoft just don't care. Wikipedia has 2.5 million articles all in the same namespace and still manage to have nice URLs. It really doesn't take much effort to provide decent URLs for a very large corpus of information - but Microsoft clearly haven't even thought about the problem. Their URLs have always been disgracefully bad.
- tptacek 18y agoThis is more a disagreement about the value of URLs than about whether Microsoft "cares" about their end users. With a keyword bookmark for Wikipedia, I'm about 50/50 for getting the content I want with simple URLs; I still wind up in the Wikipedia search bar all the time. Nobody has a foolproof scheme.
- brfox 18y agoDon't worry, many people use one password everywhere, so websites like Yelp probably already have lots of email passwords - even those that don't use any of those providers.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- dreish 18y agoIt is painful to be reminded of how poorly so many people watch out for themselves. As an uninterested third party, you can shrug and say, "Every man for himself." But as soon as you start designing web applications that assume people behave reasonably, you lose the luxury of being able to ignore the problem.
- michael_dorfman 18y agoTalk about a Coding Horror! What are these people thinking?
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- noonespecial 18y agoI think the big red FAIL said it best.
- Rickasaurus 18y agoThis is a huge blunder a lot of companies are making. I was shocked when I saw it on facebook. And now, with all the APIs available, it's simply inexcusable.
- cstejerean 18y agothe one or two times I had to use this feature on a site I changed my email password before and after.
- dfranke 18y agoHad to use it? To me that'd be an instant click of the back button and maybe a new iptables entry.
- TrevorJ 18y agoThey aren't the only ones asking for this. However, I notice that you have the option of skipping that steps, just as you do on Twitter when it asks for the same info. Just opt out.
- byrneseyeview 18y agoHis point wasn't that you have to do it, but that it's a bad option to give people.
- schtog 18y agoyeah ive seen this on several places lately, cant remember a specific instance though. my reaction is like "wtf ofc im not gonna give you my emailpassword".
- ojbyrne 18y agoMost recently I've seen one on plurk.com. They seem to be spreading like a virus - hopefully this article will help to turn people against them.
- dreish 18y agoI suspect it will only end in a courtroom, one way or another.
- ComputerGuru 18y agoI highly doubt that. Freedom of speech covers your right to give out your password to anyone who asks for it :) If some stranger came up to you in the street and asked for your SSN & bank account number and you were stupid enough to give it to them, who would be at fault? Would that stranger have done anything illegal?
- dreish 18y agoAh, you're right. No one has ever been sued for mishandling private data.
- DougBTX 18y agoThere are probably computer misuse laws which make it illegal to use someone else's identity to gain access to a secured account, just like laws against using someone else's credit card details. Certainly against the TOS of those web sites.
- babul 18y agoWe have to remember that email-based import is a service aimed at the masses to make life easier for such people. Although most people on HN and the like will usually opt out or refuse such a request, many people will not care about the privacy/security issues if it means less work for them.
- rglullis 18y agoExactly. If there is an opportunity to find a way to add features and get more users, any company will do it. This is a no-brainer. Any tech-savvy user will just simply skip this step. And the contacts API that the major providers are giving are recent. It's not like services like Yelp and FB had the choice before. Ps.: Jeff Atwood's "from the hip" writing style shows. I'm yet to find one single post from him that seems slightly insightful. Instead of spending so much time ranting, he could spend a tenth of that time thinking about why Yelp keeps that "feature". Edit: could someone please explain me why of such aggresive downmodding?
- BrandonM 18y agoBecause you completely missed the point. It doesn't matter why Yelp keeps that "feature". It's irrelevant, because his position is that there is no situation where giving a login and password of any sort, but especially e-mail, makes any sense at all. You said that Atwood should have spent time thinking instead of just ranting, but then you kind of did the same thing.... And that's not to mention giving the "they're a company, anything goes" and "it was the only way back then" excuses; those are meaningless.
- rglullis 18y agoIt may make no sense to you, to me or to any tech-savvy user. But it does make sense to those who use the damn feature. No one is forced to use that. If they are using it, it's because they think it might benefit them in some way. The same goes for websites that do such thing. They know that some users might be annoyed by such "feature", but the amount of new users that will be exposed is much higher, so they keep doing it. What I find hard to believe is that the ones that complain about these kinds of mechanisms don't understand that themselves are not part of the target of said mechanism. Instead of simply ignoring it, they feel "victims" of it. And I'd like to know where I said "anything goes". If that was the case, I would say that scammers are right to do what they do because they never forced the users to give sensitive data. What I did say is that, if a webservice wanted to provide a way for the user to (semi-)automatically invite people in his contact list, the only way to do that required email and the password. Better now?
- kmt 18y agoI first saw this on Facebook. They did have leverage and they used it without hesitation (quite arrogantly I thought). Then everyone else followed: "if Facebook can do it, why can't we?". It became a standard. That alone made me loose the little respect I had for Facebook. Very early did they screw up. Google still manage to not fall this low.
- LogicHoleFlaw 18y agoLots of phraudsters use this sort of technique as well. I started receiving several spam IMs a day from a friend of mine. When I asked what was up, she said that she had foolishly given her account name and password to a service which purported to tell her what other IM accounts had blacklisted her. Of course, many more accounts blacklisted her once they started receiving the spam messages...
- mcormier 18y agoHow insightful. Atwood states the obvious yet again.
- raganwald 18y agoIt is sad that these things need to be said.
- lvecsey 18y agoWhen you ask your employer that 'why' question, what comes next? Suppose the address book API's were unknown to both employer and employee; the employer might say 'go ahead and write the core component that will manage just a list of names and emails'. This is still ethical because in theory it can be connected to a current or future address book API, so the programmer agrees. Later, when the address book API's aren't enough for marketing, an intern or other willing employee is induced to connect it to the full email login and password credentials. Its stuff like this that makes the first employee want to leave, which leaves the 'salt' effect of remaining employees at the company. Somehow, the employees (and perhaps students in a school situation) should have some power of a social vote that the boss at least 2 levels up from them needs to acknowledge.
- Darmani 18y agoBest temporary solution for those who want the features without risk from all but the most malicious sites: Change E-mail password, give password, change password back.
- smelendez 18y agoThat's OK if you trust the site as much as you trust your email provider. There's still a mild risk that they'll store data that they obtained when they logged in to screen-scrape for contacts and that data will leak. It's probably worse in gmail and other services that show potentially confidential snippets of emails as soon as you log in.
- gommm 18y agoBy the way, for those who worry about this... Don't do like I did and try to login to your msn account in a webcafe in china.... It's the same as giving out your passport on untrusted website except that in this case, you can be sure that if they do have keylogger, (like they did in my case) they will spam the hell out of your address book.... And like this, me, who always spent my times complaining against people who are not careful about security, spammed most of my friends :-(