4 ms·
As soon as Sony files a lawsuit they bring the government (and therefore the first amendment) into the picture.
by erikpukinskis 16y ago
As soon as Sony files a lawsuit they bring the government (and therefore the first amendment) into the picture.
- dangrossman 16y agoOne of the court's primary purposes is to uphold agreements where one party has contracted away their right to some speech (NDAs, terms of service agreements, exclusivity agreements, etc). The only time a court upholds the first amendment is when striking down a law made by congress, a state or a local government as unconstitutional. Read the bill of rights. They are limitations on the power of government.
- tomrod 16y agoNo. The government cannot make law restricting the freedom of speech. But legally signing away your freedom of speech is an enforceable contract. It has nothing to do with "bringing in the government, ERGO freedom of speech". That is not the way litigation works.
- burgerbrain 16y agoI didn't sign shit when I bought my PS3. Sony isn't requesting that the US government enforce for them a contract that I signed fair and square, they're just using the court system as their own personal goon-squad.
- regularfry 16y agoA contract doesn't have to be signed to be enforceable.
- kevinpet 16y agoDebatable. Well, technically correct of course, it doesn't have to be signed. But it's an open question where the lines are drawn with regard to agreeing to a contract you never read and understood.
- yardie 16y agoAnd not all contracts are enforcable. ATT got slapped pretty hard by saying you are unable to sue by agreeing to this contract. You give up some rights in a contract but certainly not all.
- chopsueyar 16y agoEspecially all those "robo-signed" foreclosure documents. http://www.businessinsider.com/dead-womans-name-robo-signing-martha-kunkle-2010-12 http://www.businessinsider.com/dead-womans-name-robo-signing...
- wtallis 16y agoSigning away your freedoms in a contract is sometimes legal and enforceable. However, even if the language of the contract is clear, it can be invalidated for being unconscionable or for lack of consideration.