8 ms·
Milton’s notes on Shakespeare appear to have been found
- EGreg 7y agoSo Shakespeare was real after all! That take, Anonymous the movie :)
- CrazyStat 7y agoThis is about Milton reading and annotating the published collection of Shakespeare's plays, not Milton meeting Shakespeare in person. It doesn't have any bearing on the debate over Shakespeare's identity. The title is a little misleading.
- AdmiralAsshat 7y agoMilton would have been not yet eight years old when Shakespeare died, to boot, so I'm not sure a physical meeting would have meant much to him.
- dev_dull 7y agoPeople would be talking about him/her during that time, so I think their observation would have been very relevant had they made one about the identity.
- ErotemeObelus 7y agoVery few historians doubt Shakespeare's identity. Wikipedia doesn't even categorize him as "people's whose existence is disputed."
- CrazyStat 7y agoYou're right, I shouldn't have even called it a debate.
- seamyb88 7y agoI like to learn when I read, which is why I've never read Shakespeare (voluntarily).
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoYou're learning about how people thought and felt during the 16th century, and about how those people related to both their fellow man and the past (ie. Julius Ceasar). There's quite a bit to learn in Shakespeare, you just gotta be able to read between the lines.
- chmielewski 7y agoExactly this. I've heard people say that Dickens wrote amazing historical fiction - well, no, he wrote popular fiction.
- seamyb88 7y agoAt least there was injustice highlighted in Dickens. Shylock the Jew wants a pound of flesh, in any interpretation of the work, teaches you nothing except Shakespeare was just another man of his times, who said words goodly.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoReally? It doesn't teach us how the English (or Shakespeare writing to the English) thought about the Jews and their role in society? Cause I'd suggest it does. Just because the portrayal doesn't align with our modern values doesn't mean it has no value. How do we know what a "man of his times" would think without these works?
- mellosouls 7y agoShakespeare was actually empathetic enough to have called out across the centuries to very different people, as well as being supreme in his use of words and ideas. There is nothing "just another man of his times" about him. -- He wrote it for me. "When in disgrace with fortune in men's eyes / I all alone beweep my outcast state / and trouble deaf heaven with my bootless cries / and look upon myself and curse my fate / wishing me like to one more rich in hope / featured like him, like him with friends possessed / desiring this man's art and that man's scope / with what I most enjoy contented least. . . ." Of course he wrote it for me; that is a condition of the black woman. Of course, he was a black woman. I understand that. Nobody else understands it, but I know that William Shakespeare was a black woman. - Maya Angelou. http://bardfilm.blogspot.com/2015/04/shakespeare-was-black-woman-maya.html http://bardfilm.blogspot.com/2015/04/shakespeare-was-black-w...
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoI put the cam.ac.uk post on this up a couple days ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20969349 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20969349
- branweb 7y agoThanks! I like your linked article quite a bit more. The photos comparing known-milton handwriting to the folio in question adds a lot.
- calhoun137 7y agoThis is the better link. Omg I love this guys humble style. If I ever think I have made a big discovery in math or physics I am totally going to present it like this: "You know how I am always coming up with bad ideas that turn out to be wrong, well I just had another one. No big deal, silly me I can't help myself [big sigh] This is so embarrassing, but I think gravity and quantum physics could be related by ...
- toss1 7y agoLast paragraph, the discoverer is quoted: >> This is evidence of how digital technology and the opening up of libraries [could] transform our knowledge of this period. Indeed! Just bringing many more eyes (and perhaps AIs) to the works can vastly accelerate the growth of knowledge, and they're already doing further research based on this discovery. Who knows how many more centuries this knowledge might have languished unrecognized, just sitting in the stacks? And how much more like it is still awaiting?
- benbreen 7y agoAgreed - and if anyone is interested in this specific sort of work ("meta-textual" analysis of things like marginalia and the material characteristics of a piece of writing) there is a wonderful resource in Rare Book School at the University of Virginia: https://rarebookschool.org https://rarebookschool.org. They offer summer classes and a fellowship program, and it isn't just about old books - when I was there I met people working on digital texts, and even things like the preservation and archiving of VHS tapes and other old analog formats. Nick Wilding's discovery of a forged Galileo manuscript is another fun example of this type of research: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2013/12/16/a-very-rare-book https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2013/12/16/a-very-rare-bo...
- eitally 7y ago+1! I studied under Terry Belanger there as an undergrad and it was one of the most rewarding experiences of my time in university.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gumby 7y agoI admit I only skimmed the article but it I didn't see it say that Milton actually physically met Shakespeare, right: this is simply a metaphorical use? Doesn't detract from the excitement of the article, I just would love to think how the elder might have influenced the younger.
- commandlinefan 7y agoI'd think it would have to be metaphorical, if Wikipedia is correct - Wikipedia says Shakespeare died in 1616 and Milton was born in 1608... so if they did meet, there was no great exchange of ideas there.
- gumby 7y agoThanks, and blush for not doing my homework myself.
- commandlinefan 7y agoWell, don’t give me too much credit. I had to look it up because I was surprised to learn that Shakespeare and Milton were alive at the same time - but if I had been on a gameshow, I would have guessed that Milton lived and died hundreds of years before _Shakespeare_ was born.
- bobcostas55 7y ago...and of course they're hoarding them instead of just putting up a torrent of high-res scans.
- roland00 7y agoIt is a public library and they are already putting it out a display open to the public (instead of keeping it in records in the back.) They are also making available other Milton stuff they have on hand such as a 1st edition of Paradise Lost. Free Library of Philadelphia's Parkway Central branch 1901 Vine St., Philadelphia, PA 19103 Shakespeare First Folio on Display Monday, Sept. 16, through Saturday, Oct. 19 Source: https://www.phillyvoice.com/free-library-display-shakespeare-first-folio-rare-book-department/ https://www.phillyvoice.com/free-library-display-shakespeare...
- canjobear 7y agoI see a lot of evidence that these annotations are similar to Milton’s style. But the question is, are they more similar to Milton’s style than to any other random literati of the time? Has this been looked at?
- StavrosK 7y agoMy understanding is that we already had the notes, we just recognized that they're Milton's, is that correct?
- CrazyStat 7y agoCorrect.
- StavrosK 7y agoSo why is this so groundbreaking? At most, I'd expect it to be an interesting anecdote.
- mirimir 7y agoBecause we care about what Milton wrote a lot more than we care about what some random book buyer wrote.
- StavrosK 7y agoWhy? We obviously read the notes and we didn't especially care for them before we found out they were Milton's, so why is that? This implies that we care more about a famous person writing dreck than an anonymous person writing fantastic insights.
- nwj 7y agoIf you had asked me 5 minutes prior to reading about this, who was the earlier writer - Milton or Shakespeare? - I would have said Milton. I now know that it's the opposite. Shakespeare preceded Milton. There's something about Shakespeare's writing that feels closer to modernity though. Milton seems sort of medieval, perhaps because of the religious themes (and the fact that I've only read a small portion of Paradise Lost...).
- jacobolus 7y agoMultiple people have suggested this here. It seems very strange to me, since Shakespeare is one of the most famous Englishmen of the Elizabethan era, and Milton was politically active 50+ years later during the English Civil War.
- kragen 7y agoPeople in the US don't even know there was an English Civil War.
- jfengel 7y agoA surprising number of English people don't know that there was an English Civil War. When you've got a thousand years of continuous history to pack in, Oliver Cromwell ends up being kind of a footnote. Maybe if it had occurred before Shakespeare, instead of after, he could have written a cycle of plays about it, and we'd remember it as well as the Wars of the Roses. But as it is, English schoolchildren forget it as soon as class is over... and I suspect the rest of the UK cares even less.