3 ms·
I don't believe any of those qualities need be eschewed. Personal just means thinking of god as a person, benevolent meaning that they generally have good inten
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago
I don't believe any of those qualities need be eschewed. Personal just means thinking of god as a person, benevolent meaning that they generally have good intent, and caring meaning they actually give a damn about our wellbeing.
All of these things can be true and yet still produce the conditions we observe. For instance, god could be flawed or not have complete control over their creation, or the purpose for their creation necessitates that a certain amount of suffering occur. Consider that parents could prevent their children, whom they love, from being injured or emotionally harmed, and yet they do not for a wide variety of reasons. In fact, they inflict a certain amount of suffering on their own child under the belief that it is necessary to reduce suffering in the future.
- Nursie 7y ago> Personal just means thinking of god as a person No, it means one that is interested in and has a relationship with the individual. > For instance, god could be flawed or not have complete control over their creation, Then they are not omnipotent, something we are usually told that montheistic gods are. > Consider that parents could prevent their children, whom they love, from being injured or emotionally harmed, and yet they do not Frickin eyeball worms. I give up at this point, AFAICT you're just being obtuse for the sake of it. A person that invented and released something that blinded children, causing agony as it did so would be considered evil. Hands down. It would be no defence whatsoever were they to say afterwards "You're not seeing the bigger picture! I'm helping humanity to help itself!". I'm not really aware of any moral code that would say "Oh that's OK" outside of some freakish eugenics mindset or maybe the actual Nazis. I'm not sure why you think a creator god should be allowed to do the same and still be considered "benevolent".
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoYou're being stubborn, clinging to a singular notion of what god is in order to label it as malevolent. Of course the god you envision is malevolent, because that's how you designed it!
- Nursie 7y agoNo, I haven't designed such a thing, it's what major monotheistic religions have designed and try to sell. That's literally the point of the conversation, and one you repeatedly seem to ignore.