4 ms·
These bonds are fine if they're rated properly. On the other hand, if your rating system is not functioning properly (as was true in 2008) then any product that
by tialaramex 7y ago
These bonds are fine if they're rated properly. On the other hand, if your rating system is not functioning properly (as was true in 2008) then any product that needs rating is suspect, only investments whose provenance you can directly investigate yourself are safe in that case.
Maybe we can blind the rating system? If Standard & Poor can't tell whether this instrument they're rating was created by HSBC or me in my basement, they may take a few seconds more to consider whether the scent of shit is because it is in fact just shit in a thin paper shell.
And if you blind them but they still don't give true ratings you can trivially exploit that to fill the market with highly rated shit, destroying the market but leaving the real economy largely untouched. Rinse and repeat until all the dumb money is sucked into your pocket.
- JackFr 7y agoThe yield on the bond is a pretty good indicator that something is amiss. If you're making 100bps over other AAA paper, it's unlikely that you got a really good deal. It's more likely what you're holding isn't really AAA.
- Timothycquinn 7y agoYou are correct that the ratings system is fundamental to the breakdown of these systems. I don't believe we really fixed those corruption issues. I'm looking forward to seeing some analysts of the ratings from independents vs S&P etc. We also cannot downplay the significance of speculation systems themselves. There needs to be more burdens put on such financial mechanisms to prevent them from getting out of hand like in 2008.
- cm2187 7y agoThe problem is that investors do not want to pay for independant research, particularly a rating where it would require the agency to do a lot of due dilligence on a transaction rather than simply rely on audited financial statements as they usually do for a regular company.
- xchaotic 7y agowell if they paid more, it could take out any profitability from a product where real returns after fees are already very low
- cm2187 7y agoAgree. Which is why the issuer is currently paying for it. But with the obvious potential conflict of interest. Plus these are securities, and all market participants should have access to the same public information. It is a problem to have half the investors in the dark about the transaction if they couldn't pay for a private rating (which in turn would negatively affect pricing).
- turk73 7y agoThe repackaging of bonds and the fake ratings were a criminal act that has never been prosecuted. Taxpayers took it up the usual place. They took mostly junk, sprinkled in a little non-junk, and voila, a perfect AAA rating! It was fucking magic!
- gnode 7y agoCorruption is one issue, but as I understand it there are also technical issues. The synthesis of derivative investments like collateralized debt obligations involves modelling the probabilities of default. If the models are wrong, such as assuming probabilistic events are not correlated (e.g. that mortgage default is a microeconomic phenomenon of individual hardship, rather than macroeconomic recession), then the ratings will not be sensible. Robust ratings require economic science to be robust.
- bko 7y agoIt's difficult to accurately predict something that has never happened. Prime ARM delinquencies shot up to 10% in 2008 and eventually to nearly 20%. Subprime ARMs shot up to over 40% at their peak. Prior to that subprime ARMS delinquencies peaked at just over 10% at their worse. The borrowers were different so there was really no precedent, but just a cursory review of historical data would make what we experienced highly unlikely. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subprime_mortgage_crisis#/media/File:Mortgage_delinquencies_by_loan_type_-_1998-2010.GIF https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subprime_mortgage_crisis#/medi...
- statusquoantefa 7y agowell, it's difficult to predict on the one hand. on the other hand, it is easy to predict that: when the average joe holds "home ownership" up as the sterling example of "making it"; then the average politician will determine that the best way to make voters happy is to increase home ownership by lowering barriers, and exempting home ownership from risk, taxes, estates, bankruptcy, medical expenses, etc. all in the name of "obvious" fairness; then [it's easy to predict that]: mortgages and mortgage backed institutions will become unsound. TL;DR a crisis like this is going to happen again, and it happened before, see previous "savings and loan" crisis. bonus lesson in finance/accounting: if the problem is framed and worded properly, it's easy to see that money paid for rent is not actually "wasted money down the drain", and that it is a fallacy that it is better to put the money toward a mortgage. Let's say out of college you live in your old room at mom's while you save money to get your own place. Your job turns out well and you're making good money, but instead of renting your own apt, you stay at mom's to save for a down payment on a first house. You save up, and you buy a place. OK so far? Now owning your own place, do you move into it? Well, think about it, you could stay at mom's and rent this new place you own out to somebody else and let them "waste the rent" while you collect all this fingerquotes "free money". Id est, i.e., if you move into your new place, you are essentially depriving yourself of the rent that you are entitled to earn from it; you effectively pay rent to live in your owned home. You are the one "wasting the rent money". And the extra details actually work against you: mortgage interest expense is tax deductible, right? Well, if you rent the place out, ALL expenses are tax deductible, that's more deductions than if you live in a place. As an additional point, is rent "such a waste of money to the tenant" that wealthy people (let's use Bill Gates as an example) buy lots and lots of houses and apartments to rent out to the rental suckers? no, they don't. TL;DR purely financially, owning is not better than renting; rent is not wasted money, at least not more than the fingerquotes rent you spend when you live in your own place.
- curiousgal 7y agoIt's not just about the ratings. If a person is too risky you simply don't lend them money.
- AndrewDucker 7y agoBut where "too risky" lies is very-much a personal decision. It's the rating on the debt which makes it clear exactly how risky it is, and allows people to make a decision about it.
- ambicapter 7y ago> But where "too risky" lies is very-much a personal decision. What? No. Its a statistical decision. Its a question of how good your data on your risk profile and the risk the creditee represents is.
- jandrewrogers 7y agoThe rating system has been materially modified since 2008 to reduce the risk. In 2008, the designated rating companies (NRSROs) had explicit legal immunity for the correctness of their ratings, which incentivized them to sell their ability to produce ratings that optimize for goals other than correct representation of risk. And they did. The Dodd-Frank bill passed in 2010 removed this immunity, making them liable for bad faith ratings that did not represent the real risk. As some people may recall, this created a temporary problem in the market as many debt instruments were suddenly re-rated to eliminate this legal liability. This is also related to the downgrade of US Treasury debt from AAA status in 2011.
- tialaramex 7y agoI'm doubtful that a liability for "bad faith ratings" is enough to get the job done. Remember Arthur Anderson. They're gone, but the US Supreme Court concluded that they weren't guilty! They make O J Simpson look like the picture of innocence, and yet somehow the Supreme Court felt the need to grant certiorari and then decide actually people who do crimes aren't necessarily guilty of those crimes if they're rich old white men...
- simonh 7y agoBut by that time Arthur Andersen had gone from 24,000 employees to about 200. It was utterly wiped out. I don't think that's enough, David Duncan in particular should have gone to jail, but it's not as if there were no consequences and to be fair to the US government they went after AA hard.
- La-ang 7y agohttp://www.business-superstar.com/words-of-wisdom/the-truth-about-the-death-of-arthur-andersen/ http://www.business-superstar.com/words-of-wisdom/the-truth-...
- tialaramex 7y agoHilarious, one of the foxes (a partner at Arthur Anderson) writes an article explaining that those chickens actually wanted to be eaten really and anyway how can it be his fault when any responsible farmer would use stronger locks to keep him out. I particularly enjoyed: > They were indicted for shredding documents. These documents were drafts and other items that do not support the final product. All accounting firms establish policies for routinely shredding such documents. See - all routine. Sure, your routine might not include being "reminded" to arrange for piles of documents to be urgently shredded once you hear investigators are coming but that's why you might some day be found guilty of crimes, whereas Arthur Anderson were "not guilty" after all the evidence was destroyed and their chums in the US Supreme Court reached in and overturned verdicts against them for destroying the evidence. Now, one of the nice things in overseeing the Web PKI is that I don't care whether the auditors are incompetent or crooked, it's the same either way to me. I don't expect even their own bosses to do as much as slap them on the wrist for enabling fraud. If I'm relying on audit then I know I might as well toss a coin, I'm always going to be digging deeper than that to understand what was actually going on regardless of whether the auditors "forgot" or deliberately chose not to look.
- rtkwe 7y agoWeren't there also chains of derivatives based off the same mortgages too with each of them being insured? I wasn't paying much attention back then but it seemed like that was one of the biggest issues because when mortgage started failing in large numbers it affected whole chains of derivative products and all of them triggered insurance at the same time.
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoThe problem with rating systems is they are third-party. If you want to knowingly package assets with a poor grade bad at a better rating, you will shop around until you find a rater who will give you the grade you want. It becomes the cost of doing business. It takes one bad seed to mis-grade. What's worse is, the rating agency that grades fraudulently will get paid more, since the one's trying to maintain integrity won't want to mis-grade. Broader point here: grading systems aren't all that resilient. It only takes one bad actor to threaten the whole system, if we assume ratings (in aggregate) are always believable. Dodd-Frank may have been re-worked but I wouldn't, for a second, assume there isn't a loophole in there that will allow the bad guys to resume.
- LatteLazy 7y agoAnother approach would be making raters pay the first percent or two of any default.