4 ms·
I don't think that necessarily follows. Suffering is a necessary component of growth, and so maybe it isn't unreasonable that a god allows their creation to suf
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago
I don't think that necessarily follows. Suffering is a necessary component of growth, and so maybe it isn't unreasonable that a god allows their creation to suffer in order to grow. If human beings spent their lives in an idyllic garden of Eden, what would we be? Would we create art? Would we explore? Would we achieve anything? Parents often both allow and inflict suffering upon their children, but do you believe that these are acts of malevolence?
- Nursie 7y agoSo children losing their sight to a parasitic worm by age 5 is a necessary part of growth? Sorry, no, that's repellant.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoYou're thinking on an individual level, presumably a god has all of humanity to think about (at the very least, they probably concern themselves with all things that exist). If the after-life exists, then that child will have undergone a mere lifetime of suffering and then live forever in paradise. In the meantime, meankind on earth has been working to solve the problems of blindness and health care distribution, in the process learning about itself both physically and as a societal entity. When you think about it, expecting god (or the universe) to invest its full attention in you and your problems is really quite entitled. But let's suppose you had it your way and there was no suffering anywhere. How would god achieve that? I imagine the only way is to force everyone to do the right thing at all times, thus eliminating the concept of free will, and then what even are we? Who are we to demand both the freedom to act as we wish and freedom from consequences? I was an atheist for a long time, so I get the whole 'God is a dick' thing, but when you sit down and think about it deeply I think you'll see that it is only true for a particularly disingenuous construct of god.
- Nursie 7y ago>> In the meantime, meankind on earth None of which justifies the suffering of children. >> When you think about it, expecting god (or the universe) to invest its full attention in you and your problems is really quite entitled. That's exactly what most monotheistic religions promise. >> But let's suppose you had it your way and there was no suffering anywhere. That's not an argument I'm trying to make. All of this is just squirming to relativise the unjust - the extreme suffering of children. >> when you sit down and think about it deeply I think you'll see that it is only true for a particularly disingenuous construct of god. No, when you sit down and think about it, children are being blinded by parasites at age 5.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoI wonder how much child suffering you've indirectly (or even directly!) contributed to every day? Yet you are so ready to condemn a being who would merely allow said suffering.
- Nursie 7y agoA being who allegedly, omnipotently, created such suffering. Yes, quite ready to condemn that.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoYet you create suffering throughout the world every day. Where were your clothes made? Where was your food grown? From what mines were the metals extracted for the computing device you're using to converse in this very thread? Nevermind you, though. If we accept that the universe is god's creation, then we accept that the suffering we see is a product of that creation. Consider that this may be unavoidable, and perhaps even necessary. We don't know for what purpose creation exists, do we? Consider that yes, there are challenges, yes there is suffering, but also that we have the tools to make it better. And yet, even though it is completely within our power to prevent children from being blinded by parasites, we do not. But hey, it's god's fault, right? I suppose that's easier than accepting that we're just not as good as we think we are. Much simpler to point at the sky and say 'oh, there's an omnipotent being who could snap his fingers and end this!', which may even be true, but never ask why it is that being might choose not to even though we ourselves have our reasons for not helping.
- Nursie 7y ago>> Yet you create suffering throughout the world every day I did not create a worm which bores into the eyes of children and blinds them, en masse, and has done so for millions of years. I'm sure my actions have had negative consequences, but I'm not an omnipotent creator, nor am I arguing that I am perfect and benevolent. > Consider that this may be unavoidable, and perhaps even necessary. We don't know for what purpose creation exists, do we? It would appear that it exists in order for such a god to torment and destroy its creations. You're making my argument for me there - a god that invents these forms of suffering is clearly not a benevolent god, and may have all sorts of other motives. >> And yet, even though it is completely within our power to prevent children from being blinded by parasites, we do not. But hey, it's god's fault, right? The one does not preclude the other - we can be bastards for not fixing it and god can be a bigger bastard for inventing it in the first place and letting it and its kin run rampant for millions of years. >> I suppose that's easier than accepting Oh please, this is another line of argument I am absolutely not making "God is awful therefore we are perfect", where did I lead you to think that I was making such a bizarre argument?
- JetSpiegel 7y ago> You're thinking on an individual level, presumably a god has all of humanity to think about That's even worse! All those dead children are just a way for the privileged people to understand how good they have it. Be grateful for what scraps I give you and reduce yourself to your insignificance, peasant!