3 ms·
"The elements in the same column and rows share some properties" While this is what most are taught, in my opinion this is not the best way to understand it an
by adrian_b 7y ago
"The elements in the same column and rows share some properties"
While this is what most are taught, in my opinion this is not the best way to understand it and this can actually lead to mistakes.
The chemical properties of the elements are mostly determined by 3 characteristics: valence, electronegativity and size.
Valence and electronegativity are usually similar for elements in the same column and size is usually similar for elements in the same row.
This is the cause for the similarities in columns and rows. However, while the electronegativity and the size have quasi-periodic variations with the atomic number, there are various reasons that shift their similar values in adjacent rows, so that there are many cases when there are much more similarities between elements in different columns than between those in the same column. Usually for the heavy elements grouping them by column is much more useful than for the light elements, which can be more similar to elements in the same row or to elements in a diagonal position.
For example, due to their closer electronegativity and size, carbon and sulfur resemble much more to each other than to silicon or oxygen.
As another of the many examples, in the first row of the transition metals the maximum density and the change from hexagonal to cubic structure is located at cobalt-nickel, but in the next 2 rows it is shifted to ruthenium-rhodium and osmium-iridium.
There is a huge number of such examples, so that anyone who wants to understand the similarities between chemical elements must not use directly the column and row numbers but must know how the electronegativity, the atomic size and the valence vary within the periodic table.
- gus_massa 7y agoI agree. The column bellow Boron is a zoo. (Boron probably deserve a category for itself.) The non-metal part is delimited by a diagonal (and the border is fuzzy). Some columns are useful, I, II, VIII, VII, perhaps VI. That's at least half of the main groups. Other parts are not so clear. But it is possible to use the grid structure to make some approximations and predictions of the properties.