4 ms·
The difference is you get to choose what to verify. Science says you can use electricity to turn water into oxygen and hydrogen and then burn them to get water
by Retric 7y ago
The difference is you get to choose what to verify.
Science says you can use electricity to turn water into oxygen and hydrogen and then burn them to get water again. It further says what the flame will look like and how much heat it will produce etc etc. Now, if any of that seems unlikely it’s fairly cheap to verify, if something else bothers you then verify that.
Sure, verification of every idea is impossible, but pick a few at random and that should logically give you more confidence in the others.
On the other hand with matters of faith you can’t verify any of it. Which should then give you some pause.
- gavePause 7y agoAnd so, you idle for a moment, granting precisely that obligatory pause to the void of uncertainty. And then what? Nothing is gained in the pause. Or at least not very much. Sure, you rinse off some of the tedious superstition and boil away a little bargaining and gambler's luck. But then? You still come up empty handed, robbed of answers to serious questions. Why must I ride along, railroaded into this role as singleton pilot of such a lowly meatbag, less than a dust speck, bound tidally to barely a pebble swirling in the limitless void? Granted no memory of a world prior to my birth, and all this experience doomed to be forgotten at the moment of my death. Seemingly a brief gap of awareness illuminating some strange landscape trapped between bookends of pitch black eternal nothingness, suspended without gravity in yet more nothingness. So, matters of faith, you say? Faith indeed. Then why continue the charade of this deception? If this world insists on denying me any rightful understanding of this predicament, the only rational action might just be to shun this life forced upon me. Find a quick exit and escape the cosmic unfairness of such a nightmare.
- nefitty 7y agoThis is a great way to frame the counterargument. I'm wary of the comparison between religious faith and scientific belief because it seems to sometimes trigger a cascade of irrational beliefs if it goes the wrong way.
- em-bee 7y agoreligion largely claims to make your life better by teaching you how to interact with each other. it uses believe and fear of an unprovable entity to do that, sure. but you can verify if it does make your and everyone elses life better or not. those that claim to be messengers of god should be recognized by their fruits, that is, by the effect they have on society.