9 ms·
Almost one-fifth of Britons 'do not use internet'
- dazc 7y agoA lot of public services and utilities have shifted their customer facing operations to the web and the very people who struggle to interact with these services are often the ones who need them the most. Factor in that a lot of these web-based services are poorly designed and badly constructed and it is no wonder that some people get frustrated or are easily swindled. Local council sites tend to be the worst, in my experience, with unfathomable navigation and broken forms being the most common problems. My dad often asks 'why can't I do x?' and my usual answer is that the website is sh1t, there is nothing you can do about it.
- petepete 7y agoA lot of work goes into making GOV.UK sites accessible to people who aren't au fait with technology. From the design of form elements and wizards to the extreme care in choosing the correct language. It's a huge project and driven by user research and testing. Best part, almost all of it happens in the open https://design-system.service.gov.uk https://design-system.service.gov.uk https://design-system.service.gov.uk/community/backlog https://design-system.service.gov.uk/community/backlog The technology and design should eventually filter down to localised services.
- dazc 7y agoIt's a long time coming Pete.
- kingkongjaffa 7y agoLmao the local councils have been left to run their own web services and they are painfully backwards and outdated, payment portals for council tax from the early 2000’s, sites that are not responsive by default, dead/missing links. From what I have seen they are left to do their own thing a little too much.
- petepete 7y agoYeah, we can lead the horse to water. A dev can get a Node or Rails app with all the correct assets and templates running in two minutes. C# and Django in a bit longer. Most of the things they'll need to build are already there, well-engineered and tested. Some councils have longstanding contracts with local companies or just have their heads in the sand. Not much more we can do. Some work on this has actually been started https://localdigital.gov.uk/funding/leeds-city-council-2/ https://localdigital.gov.uk/funding/leeds-city-council-2/ Edit: just read the assessor's comments, pretty damning. Doesn't sound like the project delivered much - pretty sure I could do more in an afternoon
- PorterDuff 7y ago"A lot of public services and utilities have shifted their customer facing operations to the web and the very people who struggle to interact with these services are often the ones who need them the most." Well, that's the thing isn't it? Personally, I think I'd be happy, and probably better off, with an internet that consisted of email, USENET, and Amazon. (maybe eBay, although I could do without it). Unfortunately, the rest of the world and it's needs and addictions tends to drag you along.
- dazc 7y agoI agree, in principal, but amazon's retail operation succeeds because it works and puts no barriers in front of people who want to buy stuff. One might think this is 'basic internet 101' but the majority of other retail sites prove otherwise?
- Zenst 7y agoIt would be nice to know how they did this survey, I'm presuming it wasn't an online survey. But us Brits do love to lie to people doing surveys, just to get away from them. Indeed, had they done this as an online survey - they would still get people saying they do not use the internet.
- bibinou 7y ago> the OII survey visited people in their homes and gathered a more detailed view of Britons' online lives.
- benj111 7y agoLarge surveys used to be done via the phone. I think they're moving over to online surveys now. Id be more concerned about the self selecting nature. There must be quite a limited demographic willing to sign on to Yougov say, and complete surveys for a very small financial reward.
- Zenst 7y agoMore so when the sample sizes will be within a timeframe (during 9-5 usually) as well as being limited in size (very small samples given the scale) and in this case 2,000 people is about 0.0003% of the population they project those results upon.
- pmyteh 7y agoIt's an increasing struggle to get a good sample for surveys, as the rate of people refusing has been going up continuously since surveys were invented. This has methodological implications for survey researchers that are quite serious. Some things aren't a problem, though. Survey companies definitely work outside 9-5, and the 2,000 population sample turns out to be more than enough: the sample size needed for a particular degree of statistical confidence is independent of the population size (except for very small populations) and remarkably few people are needed for a good sample. 2000 is actually pretty large for survey research, where ~1000 is pretty standard.
- bibinou 7y agoPlease fix the title, the real number is 18% (of 2000 people surveyed) Direct link to report: https://oxis.oii.ox.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/43/2019/09/OxIS-report-2019-final-digital-PDFA.pdf https://oxis.oii.ox.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/43/2019/0... very interesting numbers nonetheless.
- MiroF 7y agois that not almost one fifth?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- furyofantares 7y agoI thought parent comment was quibbling as well but it’s actually closer to one-sixth and surprisingly this does affect my reaction to the information. So I do think 18% would be a better title. The article does get there in the second line at least (but not before saying “almost 20%” for no reason other than to exaggerate, I guess.)
- rwmj 7y agoAssuming the survey methodology allows us to scale this number to the whole population, it would be nearly 12 million people (0.18 * 66 million = 11.88 million). Quite a staggering number no matter what percentage it is.
- diego_moita 7y agoHonest question: is it really worth it to try to change them? For people older than 60 years the internet is still so new that many still might think it is a "fad". It will be very, very hard to teach new tricks to old dogs. As the article says: > "There are a lot of things about the internet that get less useful as you get older," he said. OTOH, for people younger than 20, the proportion of not connected will most certainly be very low. As the article says: > "Virtually everyone is online before age 50," Dr Blank told the BBC I suspect that the effort to get the last and very reluctant old people online is just not worth it.
- Ericson2314 7y agoBut also > Earlier versions of the survey found the 50-plus drop-off in net use had persisted for a long time, said Dr Blank, suggesting it was not tied to a particular age group that grew up without the net. Given that the different survey results didn't really agreec on the basics, I'm not sure the correlation means much. But if that is true it would definitely make it more worth it.
- cstross 7y agoI've just gone through the decline and death of an elderly relative. She was able to use a Mac and browse the web a decade ago. Then she began to forget how to do things she'd been proficient at a few years earlier. In the past four years her ability to use the computer dropped to zero, and attempting to get her onto an iPad instead failed (it was too complicated/required too much learning -- I'd left it too late, not recognizing the early signs of decline). At the time of death she had medium to advanced vascular dementia; the point is, cognitive decline in old age is a real thing, and people lose the ability to do stuff they knew how to do at an earlier age.
- bonoboTP 7y ago> For people older than 60 years I think the threshold is higher now, I'd say 70 years+. 60 year olds were 40 when the Internet started to become a thing and were in their late 20s when personal computing took off in the 80s. Those are quite receptive ages still.
- phjesusthatguy3 7y agoWhoTF is the Oxford Internet Institute?[0] I understand I'm just a dumb American, but is the OII something anyone knows anything about? [0]https://www.oii.ox.ac.uk/ https://www.oii.ox.ac.uk/
- rwmj 7y agoIt's a department in the University of Oxford. Unlike all those "Oxford School of English" type of places, this one is actually noteworthy and part of the real university.
- phjesusthatguy3 7y agoThank you. It looks like what I think BuzzFeed looks like but I was wrong.
- dijit 7y agoac.uk is reserved for academic institutions in the UK (akin to .edu for Americans). ox.ac.uk is Oxford university. OII is a project stemming from this university. Something like this is akin to MITs IPRI[0] [0]: https://internetpolicy.mit.edu/ https://internetpolicy.mit.edu/
- pmyteh 7y agoThe web page you have linked literally has "A multidisciplinary research and teaching department of the University of Oxford, dedicated to the social science of the Internet" at the top of the page. The internal organisation of Oxford is definitely weird (I did my doctorate at the OII and most of the university didn't know we existed or thought we were part of computer science) but it's not that obscure.
- phjesusthatguy3 7y agomea culpa. And thank you.
- phjesusthatguy3 7y agoThis is like the time I stood up in class and said "why do I care what X had to say about this?" not knowing that X was the president of the university.
- rwmj 7y agoI posted this because I think we tend to live in a bubble where everyone carries multiple internet connected devices on their person at all times (only a slight exaggeration!). But there are over 11 million people in a first world country who don't use the internet at all, and likely many more who have access but it's limited to eg only an old desktop PC or only at work. How should internet-based start-ups react to this?
- new2628 7y agoBy leaving those people alone to continue living their lives as they like?
- 8ytecoder 7y agoIf it’s by choice, sure. A lot of people either can’t afford it or there’s no Connectivity where they live
- rwmj 7y ago> or there’s no Connectivity where they live Which unfortunately in the UK is an issue. I have no mobile phone reception at home (20 miles as the crow flies from Charing Cross station in London), so if my only access to the internet was through a phone then I might be one of these people.
- tialaramex 7y ago96% of UK premises could have "Superfast", not just "Internet" but "Superfast" broadband, which is defined as 30Mbps to the door. But you're correct that a very large fraction of the population don't choose to buy this either because they can't afford it or they don't want it. There is a Universal Service Obligation, just like in the days of voice telephony, which says the incumbent (British Telecom in most of the country) is legally obliged to offer anybody who wants it at least a minimum service (10Mbps down 1Mbps up asymmetric, so mediocre DSL basically) for a fee. In unusual cases (imagine you live on an otherwise uninhabited island for some reason or up a mountain) you may need to contribute to capital costs for installation. About 2% of the country are estimated to /live/ in places that can't get USO obligatory service (without new construction) if they asked. Unsurprisingly people who want fast Internet don't tend to buy properties with problems like that, but in principle if you were stubborn you could buy one and demand they fix it to 10Mbps up 1Mbps down. So, whatever it is the problem is not Connectivity.
- botto 7y agoI would suggest reading the original report. https://oxis.oii.ox.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/43/2019/09/OxIS-report-2019-final-digital-PDFA.pdf https://oxis.oii.ox.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/43/2019/0... Quite interesting to see that the majority of people who don't want to join the internet is because of choice and worry that they will lose their privacy. Anyone done a study of how people who don't use the internet usually vote in elections and generally feel socially about the rest of the world?
- Zenst 7y agoYes, the whole privacy concern aspect did stick out. More so than what the BBC ran with.
- Catsandkites 7y agoStatistically, the older you are in the UK the more conservative you are. It's something like 17% 18-28 but 75% 60-70. The privacy worries are weird. In my experience this is the same group that love to use loyalty/reward cards, coupons etc. To me, those are far more intrusive to my privacy than a properly set up internet connection.
- botto 7y agoSo probably the privacy concerns come from over blown news articles and reporting about latest passwords leak, information leak, hacking, exploit and any other word that remotely sounds like it's related to the internet. You should watch Sky News sometimes talk about the latest security problem, they do not take a balanced approach to the reporting.
- dghughes 7y agoI remember in the early to mid 1990s when many were amazed at the Internet this new thing called the Web. At that time I read that in the early 1990s only about 5% of the entire world were using the Internet home user would be using it via dial-up. But the shocking part was how many people in the world at that time did not even have a telephone. I can't recall the percentage but it was quite high.
- cookie_monsta 7y agoThere's scope for pretty massive sampling errors with any door to door survey like this - you only end up polling people who are home (presumably during the day), that answer their door to strangers (and not screen via camera) and are willing to answer a whole bunch of questions. That may be representative of the wider society, but amongst my acquaintances it is not.
- reaperducer 7y agoThere's scope for pretty massive sampling errors with any door to door survey like this Not necessarily. While it's common for people on HN to eschew the results of surveys because of presumed sample bias, that's rarely what happens. I took a couple of statistics classes in college that spelled out the math involved, and essentially if you survey enough people within a population of a certain size, unintentional bias gets reduced to the point where it becomes a non-factor. It's all very interesting if you're into math. I am not, but statistics courses were required for my journalism degree. ("Unintentional" meaning there is such a thing as "intentional" bias. For example, if you're deliberately surveying Toyota owners about Toyotas, or something like that.)
- cookie_monsta 7y agoYes, I don't know the maths but this study surveyed 2,000 people from a pool of around 54 million (18% of Britain's 66 million people are under 16 [1]). I don't think those numbers qualify as being enough people within a population of a certain size to avoid unintentional bias. [1] https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/populationandmigration/populationestimates/articles/overviewoftheukpopulation/november2018 https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/populati...
- reaperducer 7y ago2,000 might actually be oversampling for 66,000,000 people. When the United States had about 300,000,000 people the number for statistical veracity was around 975. Again, my statistics classes were a long time ago, so the numbers I remember are inexact. But once I groked the math, it was surprising how few people you needed to interview.
- qznc 7y agoOne aspect is that they describe themselves as not using the internet. There might be some Grandma who says that while writing a text message to her family. Does the survey make clear what "using the internet" means?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- danpalmer 7y agoI wonder whether the "internet" vs "web" distinction was made in the survey, or whether it got lost in translation to the BBC article. I'd agree, my grandmother never uses the _internet_, my grandfather used to use just email (probably once a week), but never used the _web_.
- reaperducer 7y agoDoes the survey make clear what "using the internet" means? It doesn't state explicitly, but it does not appear that text messaging, or anything you could do with a feature phone was counted. The term used in the study was "online," not "using the internet." The study looked at things like "buy products," "pay bills," "listen to music," "watch movies," "follow celebrities," "post videos," and "buy groceries."
- mcmullen 7y agoThis shouldn't surprise anybody. Anecdotally speaking, most old folks I know (of) watch television, read physical newspapers, and call/write/see people. What do they need the internet for? I'm -- if anything -- surprised the number isn't higher.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- g051051 7y agoOr perhaps it's better to phrase it "over 80% of Britons use internet".
- majewsky 7y agoDownvoted because, if you have a point to make, you forgot to include it in the post.
- g051051 7y agoClickbait headline: "Almost one-fifth of Britons 'do not use internet'" Non-clickbait version: "over 80% of Britons use internet" How is that not clear? 80% internet usage is pretty good, not bad as the headline and article suggest.
- ben_w 7y agoMy first thought is of course surprise and shock that this number is so high. My second thought is this is about the same number of British people who are below the official poverty line[1], and of course food is a higher priority than internet. (It’s still shocking that the number is so high). [1] https://m.spiegel.de/international/europe/poverty-in-nottingham-the-uk-s-worsening-problem-a-1269597.html https://m.spiegel.de/international/europe/poverty-in-notting...
- mcintyre1994 7y ago> The detailed in-home survey of almost 2,000 Britons found that 18% described themselves as non-users. I'm really curious what the methodology is here. "detailed in-home" suggests it did something more than just ask people, but then it says they "described themselves" as non-users. If you asked my mum she'd say she doesn't use the internet, but if you sat down in her house with her you'd see she uses Facebook and WhatsApp on her phone to communicate with friends and family, and occasionally accidentally clicks a link that opens a browser. But she'll never open a browser, doesn't actively use her email and would consider herself not to use the internet.