4 ms·
The death of the UNIX RISC vendors and also minicomputers creates an interesting situation where the server "middle class" is gone. We now have commodity serve
by tyingq 7y ago
The death of the UNIX RISC vendors and also minicomputers creates an interesting situation where the server "middle class" is gone. We now have commodity servers where you hardly care about the vendor on one end, and hyper engineered mainframes on the other. Not much between.
- justinjlynn 7y agoThe OpenPOWER RISC systems fit nicely in the middle-tier niche.
- tyingq 7y agoAgree, though that's basically the last gasp of the UNIX RISC vendors. I wouldn't be surprised to see them shelved soon. Not that they aren't terrific products, but demand is what it is.
- willtim 7y agoThere's an opportunity for someone to sell "reasonably" secure hardware at this price point. Especially since Intel certainly isn't selling anything that fits this description.
- coder543 7y agoI think AMD already has that covered with Epyc 2 (Rome) processors. POWER is also known for being highly SMT, which could lead to them being even more prone to the issues that plagued Intel's implementation of hyperthreading. A single POWER9 core has 4 to 8 threads.
- dralley 7y agoI would expect that it would actually be much harder to pull off such an attack, because you've got 4 threads fighting over the same resources instead of 2. These attacks essentially require statistical analysis, and the more noise there is the more difficult the attack would be. If you've got more than just the attacker and the victim threads running on a core than it's a noisier environment to pull off such an attack.
- coder543 7y agoThat’s a good point. Also imagine if the attacker controlled 7 out of the 8 threads on a core... maybe they would have even clearer statistics for analysis. Or maybe POWER9 is completely secure. My main point was that Epyc has already proven to be much more resistant to these attacks than Intel’s architecture, and it wouldn’t require dealing with porting your applications to run on a niche ISA, with very limited options to buy server hardware, and very few (if any) options to rent cloud instances on POWER9.
- rst 7y agoPeople who are troubled by security issues in Intel's Management Engine may also be suspicious of the firmware in AMD's roughly equivalent Platform Security Processor, which doesn't have a spotless record either. See, e.g., https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/01/06/amd_cpu_psp_flaw/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/01/06/amd_cpu_psp_flaw/
- coder543 7y agoI think we were talking about Spectre, Meltdown, and related attacks. Not the PSP or IME, although those are concerning too.
- floatboth 7y agoWell, Spectre affected pretty much all processors except very slow ones (Cortex-A53) :)
- coder543 7y agoIt affected AMD's Zen architecture significantly less. A number of exploits that applied to Intel didn't apply at all to Zen, and the ones that did apply had less costly mitigations than Intel.
- bogomipz 7y ago>"POWER is also known for being highly SMT, which could lead to them being even more prone to the issues that plagued Intel's implementation of hyperthreading." Which SMT issues are you referring to here on Intels?
- sgt101 7y agoNvidia dgx1?
- ianai 7y agoYou’ve got an interesting point. I could see that middle ground being filled by customized silicon. It’s more possible now with things like customizable ARM chips.
- tus88 7y agoMore and more PAAS where you don't care if the server is a mainframe or a dell 1ru.
- truth_seeker 7y agoFPGA can fill that middle path. sort of. Microsoft (Azure) is investing heavily in FPGA based configurable cloud https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v_4Ap1bjwgs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v_4Ap1bjwgs
- tyingq 7y agoNot sure why you were downvoted here. Specifically engineered systems with things like FPGA, GPU, TPU, Infiniband, Optane, "minion cores", etc, are probably the best candidates to re-establish something like a proprietary mid-range where you care who the vendor is.
- nickpsecurity 7y agoI was eyeballing the Pico Computing boxen for this: https://www.micron.com/products/advanced-solutions/advanced-computing-solutions/hpc-desktop-systems https://www.micron.com/products/advanced-solutions/advanced-... One could get a lot of mileage in many areas out of a desktop with a good CPU, lots of RAM, a graphics card for general-purpose use, and one or more FPGA's w/ HLS tooling (or just buy the modules). Especially if the basic components were standardized like the PC with minimum requirements on cores, slices, etc on each version of the platform. An app ecosystem could be developed or emerge with capabilities regular desktops couldn't match.
- bogomipz 7y agoI'm unfamiliar with the "minion cores" reference in your comment. Is this the same things as this RISCv architecture? https://www.lowrisc.org/docs/minion-v0.4/overview/ https://www.lowrisc.org/docs/minion-v0.4/overview/
- tyingq 7y agoThat's what I was referring to. The PRUs in a TI AM335X (like the BeagleBone) are similar. Basically real time capable microcontrollers that share memory with the mainstream CPU that is probably running Linux. Allows for interesting use cases, like high speed data in or out to drive LED displays, sample signals, generate audio, etc.
- pjmlp 7y agoAdditionally the mainstream adoption of high level languages, made the OS irrelevant outside some niche use cases like microcontrollers, Fintech and AAA games, for example. If the language runtime supports the platform (even bare metal), the AOT/JIT does a good enough job even exploring some vectorization and the large majority of the standard library is available, then it is just an instance of cattle OS. Which by way, has been the way that those hyper engineered mainframes from IBM (and Unisys) are designed, with their "language environments".
- ksec 7y ago>Additionally the mainstream adoption of high level languages, made the OS irrelevant outside some niche use cases like microcontrollers, Fintech and AAA games, for example. Has this really been the case though? Apps are still very much OS specific. Even Web Apps in Backend are also OS specific ( Linux Specfic ). I just don't see any "mainstream" adoption of high level languages that does this.
- pjmlp 7y agoJava. We develop on Windows and deploy on Linux, BSD, OS X, mainframes, Amazon and Azure Java runtimes.
- the8472 7y agoEven java has to deal with platform quirks. Serving files from NFS (ESTALE), hardlinks, unlinking files that are still mmaped and stuff like that. With a large enough codebase you'll accumulate some unix-specific logic where it'll be less painful to just develop under linux rather than trying to keep it running on windows. Of course those pain points are minor and you could write some fallback code for windows, but that code would only ever be exercised on developer machines.
- pjmlp 7y agoApplication servers take care of that. All data should come from databases, which also don't matter on which OSes they're running on.
- rudolfwinestock 7y agoThat's because, ultimately, mainframes and embedded computers are the only natural computer platforms. I expounded on this at length (yes, this is a self-plug). http://www.winestockwebdesign.com/Essays/Eternal_Mainframe.html http://www.winestockwebdesign.com/Essays/Eternal_Mainframe.h... Long story, short: We will really have to watch out for our privacy because those two remaining platforms give The Management(tm) an irresistible temptation to stomp on us.
- tyingq 7y agoInteresting essay. Personally, I think AWS might be the new mainframe. You're guided to a specific set of proprietary services to build solutions, not terribly unlike the heyday of CICS, VSAM, JCL, MQ, RACF, etc. The playbook of Lambda, Fargate, AWS Batch, DynamoDB, IAM/Cognito, SQS, CloudFormation, etc, looks pretty similar.
- VectorLock 7y agoAWS is absolutely the new mainframe. The big difference is that when you rent from Amazon instead of IBM they provide the building the mainframe lives in.
- goatinaboat 7y agoIn the 1970s there were companies called “mainframe bureaus” that did exactly that
- eru 7y agoAnd that's mostly because our 'dial-up lines' are better than they used to be. IBM would have been happy to rent you the building as well.
- evancox100 7y agoFyi your very first link out to the "Wheel of Reincarnation" is dead. Maybe it too needs to be reincarnated?
- 7y ago