4 ms·
> China gets the credit for 100% of the iPhone's export value, even though it is only assembling the product designed elsewhere from parts that are made elsewhe
by nostromo 16y ago
> China gets the credit for 100% of the iPhone's export value, even though it is only assembling the product designed elsewhere from parts that are made elsewhere.
More than anything, this just points to the absurdity of the way these metrics are calculated. An American company sells something to an American consumer -- along the way the product is assembled in China for tens of dollars -- and the American trade deficit between the US and China grows by $500 for each unit sold. Ridiculous.
- patio11 16y ago[edit: Had coffee, thought sardonic voice could be misconstrued, rephrased.] The calculation of national trade deficit is a matter of strategic import at a number of Japanese companies, which have scale sufficient that companywide policy registers on them. (I live in Japan's manufacturing heartland, and work professionally in the ambit of a particular company which makes, among other things, automobiles. That company is, to say things mildly, rather large.) Back in the 1980s, when the US/Japan trade deficit was a source of friction between the two countries, there was great popular unrest in the US about it, including demonstrations where Japanese cars were destroyed to make a point. This unrest predictably had concrete policy consequences. Those policy consequences materially impacted the operations of several large Japanese companies, including that automobile manufacturer. So they put their heads together with the PR teams and hacked the system. One hack was sharply curtailing the amount of final assembly they do. As I phrased it once, a Japanese chasis, Japanese camera, Japanese CPU, Japanese antenna, Japanese software, and Chinese paper box is a Chinese cell phone when the governments run their numbers. Journalists and politicians don't second guess them, because they're mostly ignorant. This keeps anti-Japan unrest to a minimum and is part of the reason why economic relations between the countries are so cordial now despite fairly little materially changing. Japan historically has a contentious relationship with China. A portion of the discontent with globalism which was once directed at Japan is now directed at China. Many here would consider this to not be a bug.
- riobard 16y agoNo, it's not. The components that China imports from elsewhere to assemble iPhones will be credited as China's import value. The same happens recursively for those countries that export the components to China until it eventually traces back to U.S. export. If you just look at the difference between China and the U.S., then yes it will look bad. But the two thing will cancel out each other in the whole system. The metric is fine. Just don't take it at face value. The sad part is that it is often abused for political reasons.
- zwieback 16y agoExactly - Looking at one product or sector or country in isolation makes no sense at all.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- nostromo 16y agoNot really. Check out this WSJ article: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704828104576021142902413796.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405274870482810457602... "Mr. Lamy said if trade statistics were adjusted to reflect the actual value contributed to a product by different countries, the size of the U.S. trade deficit with China—$226.88 billion, according to U.S. figures—would be cut in half."