4 ms·
This is almost moving Kurzweil's prediction from "mostly correct" to "correct". "Early 2000s * Translating telephones allow people to speak to each
by ghshephard 16y ago
This is almost moving Kurzweil's prediction from "mostly correct" to "correct".
"Early 2000s
* Translating telephones allow people to speak to
each other in different languages.
* Machines designed to transcribe speech into
computer text allow deaf people to understand
spoken words."
Every time he notches another victory, I pay closer and closer attention to his other guesses that are 10 - 30 years out.
- billpaetzke 16y agoPredictions made by Ray Kurzweil: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predictions_made_by_Ray_Kurzweil http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predictions_made_by_Ray_Kurzwei...
- abecedarius 16y agoHow well does this system handle your second bullet point (transcription for conversation with the deaf)? I have a use for that but, not having an Android phone yet, I can't just try it out.
- Splines 16y agoProbably just as well (as the deaf person wouldn't have to interpret the text-to-speech engine). I'd wager that this project was built on the back of GOOG-411.
- michaelbuckbee 16y agoDragon Dictate is available for both iPhone and Android which would seem sufficient for a face to face conversation (or at least better than the alternative).
- BRadmin 16y agoScreenings for a documentary about him, Transcendent Man, were finally posted yesterday: http://transcendentman.com/ http://transcendentman.com/
- nazgulnarsil 16y agoI was forced to revise my estimate in kurzweil's direction of 2040 for AI/whole brain emulation after seeing AIXI-MC, and the memristor brain project being funded by DARPA. My original estimate was more like 2080.
- pyre 16y agoInterestingly enough a search for 'AIXI-MC' turns up an OKCupid posting as the third result. And it's correct: possible instantiations of AIXI-MC or Goedel machines is listed under 'I spend a lot of time thinking about.' Though I wonder if that's a failure of Google or a failure of the popularity of the term 'AIXI-MC.'
- feral 16y agoI don't buy that Kurzweil prediction accuracy stuff. There's just so much wiggle room when you start allowing categorisations like 'mostly correct', and the sort of equivocation that seems to be going on. I thought his recent evaluation of predictions was weak. First off, this particular technology could probably have been built, very badly, in the early 90s. It would have had accuracy too low to make it useful. Its cool that google are doing this now, certainly, but the questions on accuracy and speed need to be answered. I'm sure they'll do a good job, but my point is that there is a big difference than when the technology is first prototyped in a lab, in some form, and when its mature enough for wide spread consumption. The predictions really need to say which they are referring to to be meaningful - a big problem with the recent evaluation. Further, if your thesis is that technological capacity grows exponentially, like moores law, then 8/10 years wrong is pretty wrong. Finally, I'll just say, that the charts of progress and development in the book 'The Singlularity Is Near' are hard to take seriously. Subjective technological milestones are arbitrarily chosen, sometimes over millennial timespans. These are plotted log-log, lines are fitted and inferences drawn that make predictions on for the next 30 years. What's the margin of error to a methodology like that? I'm not disagreeing with any particular thesis; his writing certain stirs healthy debate on important ideas, and its certainly worth pointing out to a whole lot of people that technological growth is non-linear. But beyond that, I'm not paying too much attention to the future predictions.
- ghshephard 16y agoI'm a huge kurzweil critic as well, and, in fact, believe he is overly generous sometimes in his "Mostly Correct" versus "Correct" category. But, seriously - you've got to give the guy credit for his "* Translating telephones allow people to speak to each other in different languages." That's a pretty far-out prediction for when he made it, and, the new Droid Apps are doing precisely that. The voice recognition stuff that Dragon does freaks me out so much that I actually don't use them - It weirds me out to see 5-10 minutes of me talking coming out with only one or two typos. It's an uncanny valley experience. I can only imagine what it's going to be like when _translation_ experiences the same increase in performance and accuracy. BTW - the entire point of Kurzweil's writing, and "singularity" thesis is precisely that the last 500+ years of technological growth are all building on each other, and a 20% growth next year is incomparable to what 20% growth was 100 years ago, presuming we had year over year growth of 20% in terms of our information processing capability. We can argue if it's 30%/year, 20% year, or 10% year - but the reality is that as long as it's 10% plus (which I think every resident of HN would agree is a conservative predictor for future technological growth for the next 20 years), the curve gets freaky very soon. Kurzweil isn't interesting in terms of the precision and absolute accuracy of his predictions - which I'll agree with you, he is overly generous - but in terms of the "class" of advances he is predicting. Basically, anything that can be translated (pardon the pun. :-) into a "Information Processing Domain" - is going to be radically transformed in terms of performance, personalization, and miniaturization. He predicted, when it was _not_ obvious - that we would have phones that would be able to translate our conversations, right around now. So, I find his prediction about things like "nanotechnological blood and organ analysis in 20 years" to be pretty darn interesting.