5 ms·
He thought he was going to get a comfortable life in Hong Kong by leaking lists of compromised systems to China. That China laughed him out of the country after
by lern_too_spel 7y ago
He thought he was going to get a comfortable life in Hong Kong by leaking lists of compromised systems to China. That China laughed him out of the country after receiving the documents does not change what he thought his trade was.
- boomboomsubban 7y agoSo in this fantasy scenario, China is fine completely screwing him over, and then let's him inform everyone what information they now have? Seems dumb.
- lern_too_spel 7y agoHe had already broadcast that he had given the information to China. https://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/article/1260306/edward-snowden-classified-us-data-shows-hong-kong-hacking-targets https://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/article/1260306/edward-s... > Seems dumb. It sure does seem dumb on Snowden's part, doesn't it? Nobody with a technical background who has read Snowden's documents and read what he thought they said has ever accused him of being smart.
- boomboomsubban 7y ago>He had already broadcast that he had given the information to China. Where in that article does it say anything like that? As the closest I can see is that he may have shown something to a Malaysian owned paper. >It sure does seem dumb on Snowden's part, doesn't it? No, why would China let him go and publicly release things? There would be so many better ways to handle him.
- lern_too_spel 7y ago> Where in that article does it say anything like that? That newspaper is based in China, which can do with information and people within its borders as it pleases. Why do you think he gave out that information out to begin with? There is no benefit to Americans. He leaked all of that and more just to expose one illegal US program (phone metadata collection). Anybody with a high school degree would think of a better way to handle that. > No, why would China let him go and publicly release things? There would be so many better ways to handle him. He did that before China knew what he was going to do. There are so many better ways for Snowden to have handled that data, yes.
- boomboomsubban 7y ago>That newspaper is based in China, which can do with information and people within its borders as it pleases. Why do you think he gave out that information out to begin with? There is no benefit to Americans. It's based in Hong Kong, and the Chinese state accessing published information isn't noteworthy. He exposed numerous illegal hacks done by the NSA on Hong Kong civilians, it's beneficial for Americans to know that their government is doing such a thing. >He leaked all of that and more just to expose one illegal US program (phone metadata collection) Your "smoking gun" on giving data to the Chinese exposes yet another illegal US program, and if you look through the other released information you'll find many more. >He did that before China knew what he was going to do. There are so many better ways for Snowden to have handled that data, yes No, according to your ridiculous fantasy, he released the information after giving it to the Chinese. It wouldn't matter what he was going to do then, letting him out of Chinese custody would be a huge mistake as it becomes advantageous for him to expose that he gave China information.
- lern_too_spel 7y ago> He exposed numerous illegal hacks done by the NSA on Hong Kong civilians These hacks are not illegal. I'm flabbergasted that you would think they were. In addition to those legal hacks on Hong Kong infrastructure, he also exposed legal hacks on mainland Chinese infrastructure. Americans already know the government is doing these things. They do not need to know the details of which systems were compromised and when, and the Chinese government especially should not know these things. Again, there is only one illegal data collection program in the terabytes of data that Snowden leaked. That is reckless and stupid at the very least and treasonous by his leaks of Chinese target details to China at worst. Did you ever stop to think why he would choose to divulge that information first, while he was in Hong Kong? > No, according to your ridiculous fantasy, he released the information after giving it to the Chinese. That is your ridiculous fantasy. I never said that.
- boomboomsubban 7y ago>The small sample data suggests secret and illegal NSA attacks on Hong Kong computers... From your source. You're flabbergasted that I think the illegal programs you brought up were illegal.