5 ms·
Can someone familiar with Libra speculate how a ban can be implemented? What comes to my mind is forbidding Facebook selling and processing it for EU users but
by mrtksn 7y ago
Can someone familiar with Libra speculate how a ban can be implemented? What comes to my mind is forbidding Facebook selling and processing it for EU users but beyond that, I am not sure how a "black market" could be prevented.
- ijonas 7y agoVery simple. Facebook is a company. You can legislate laws that determine what companies are allowed to do and what they are not allowed to do. Particularly if it concerns financial instruments. A "ban" doesn't need to be technological.
- mrtksn 7y agoHow do you stop people obtaining it and using it through their buddies on the internet? Is libra tied to an account like game money? AFAIK it's a cryptocurrency? Haven't looked at the details but cryptocurrency implies it stays on some distributed ladger and no 3rd parties have control over the transactions. Isn't that the case?
- pjmlp 7y agoYou make its use a criminal charge.
- mrtksn 7y agoI'm sure that they keep spare guillotines around but I'm not sure that it would be a popular thing to punish random Louis libra user for his few hundres Euro transaction when Facebook is paying less in taxes than him, figuratively speaking.
- pjmlp 7y agoReally? Sadly it is not uncommon to see people going to jail for stealing a few chicken because they were hungry, while many company owners and politicians hardly face any jail time for their proven corruption affairs. Being popular and law seldom come hand in hand.
- mrtksn 7y agoStealing a chicken is very different from using something. Stealing chicken is no doubt immoral for most people but punishing the usage of something that Americans can use will not fly unless the USA becomes the arch-enemy and using Libra is perceived as treason and way or unfair enrichment. Stealing a chicken has a clearly defined victim and stealing, not even piracy or patent infringement is well understood and universally condemned action.
- freddie_mercury 7y agoI'm not sure why you think this is so hard? You pass a law. Most people don't break the law. You make it illegal for banks to transfer to known Libra things. You audit people. You apply big fines. Murder is illegal but that doesn't mean nobody can commit murder.
- nextlevelwizard 7y agoMurder is also immoral. Libra is hardly morally questionable. If you want a better comparison take (software) piracy. Piracy is illegal and while I'm sure Steam, Spotify, and Netflix has reduced it a lot it is still thriving and many people break the law if not daily at least monthly. Best thing you can do is to make a law that forces banks to prevent payments to known Libra sellers, but again if there is value in Libra this hardly makes a difference. For one unless there is official list of every entity that sells them and they get instantly blocked you could just buy them before they get blocked. Secondly you could just use PayPal to transfer the money (first to your PayPal wallet and then to the seller), EU is not crazy enough to block PayPal without an alternative in sight. Secondly take any gray-market on the Internet. On these markets you can already use a range of payment methods starting with freaking Starbucks Gift Cards to just plain old cash. Yes, yes, just like most laws it will keep the honest people honest and we can assume that at least in the start that will be most of the population, but such a law would be so trivial to bypass that if there is any benefit of having some Libra people will have it and outside of completely breaking privacy of EU citizens there is nothing they can do about it.
- pjc50 7y agoIt's Facebook. If we were talking about a privacy-conscious system, maybe, but it's guaranteed to be the opposite. Facebook wouldn't do something like this without tying it to the user's FB account.
- lapnitnelav 7y agoIf murder is immoral, what are death penalty and soldiers killing other soldiers (when it's not civilians)? Besides the context (and the legal aspect), they are the same act, homicide with intent. Their morality seem to be different depending who you ask. And as for Libra being made illegal, I don't see what value it provides in EU to make it worth breaking the law.
- SanchoPanda 7y agoYou tell Facebook that if a French national is offered Libra you will fine them. If they complain they don't have the tech to prevent that. You fine them anyway. The theme here is that Facebook has lost the trust of too many important people, and maybe they just want to hurt what looks like another enormous American tech company that has been too careless and too aggressive.
- CaptainZapp 7y agoIf they complain that they're not able to identify who lives in France you bring the hammer of the law down; hard! They would just have conclusively proven that they ignore KYC regulations and are running the biggest money laundring operation ever
- alacombe 7y agoFrench citizen (even with French addresses) are not prohibited to do things which would be illegal in France but legal where they currently reside. So KYC is utterly useless in this case.
- hn_throwaway_99 7y ago> Haven't looked at the details but cryptocurrency implies it stays on some distributed ladger and no 3rd parties have control over the transactions. Isn't that the case? It's about time we all disabused ourselves of the libertarian utopian dream that just because cryptocurrency is on a distributed ledger than governments can't control it. "How do you stop people obtaining it and using it through their buddies on the internet" - quite simply, by telling them they'd go to jail, or get a hefty fine, for doing that. Companies are even easier to control than people because their whole existence is made possible by laws and regulations of governments.
- primroot 7y ago> Companies are even easier to control than people because their whole existence is made possible by laws and regulations of governments. And this is how we know the "small government" slogan is an absolute sham.
- drchaos 7y ago> "How do you stop people obtaining it and using it through their buddies on the internet" - quite simply, by telling them they'd go to jail, or get a hefty fine, for doing that. That method does not work very well for e.g. weed.
- remcob 7y agoAFAIK, the Libra design is very centralized (which follows from the throughput requirements). All usage of it would be through Facebook's servers. So that would be where you can implement any censorship.
- shakna 7y ago> Haven't looked at the details but cryptocurrency implies it stays on some distributed ladger and no 3rd parties have control over the transactions. Isn't that the case? Not quite, in the case of Libra. Only a handful of companies control the nodes. Which makes it relatively easy to enforce a ban.
- alacombe 7y agoThat's completely false. Today, you don't need to interact with the NYSE to buy stock listed in the NYSE. There is plenty on intermediaries providing the service for a fee.
- shakna 7y agoIf the half dozen nodes are required to block payments originating from a nation, then it would require illegal middlemen to accomplish that, and they can continually be shut down.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoSame as banks have to inform tax or money laundering authorities when certain types of transactions take place, you require any French bank to notify the currency crime unit of a transaction from a known Libra exchange. Maybe you fine the bank for accepting the transaction without proof it was a legal cryptocurrency.
- kazen44 7y agowhy would people want to use libra? Especially if the currency is declared illegal to use inside the EU/Eurozone. Let's not forget that the euro is a stable currency compared to most other markets libra wants to compete in (the developing world). What is in it for me as a consumer? Atleast the Eurozone has rules in place to protect my savings (up to 10.000 euro[0]). Libra brings nothing to the table in terms of transaction speed or costs either (for the consumer atleast). 1 https://www.ecb.europa.eu/explainers/tell-me-more/html/deposit_guarantee.en.html https://www.ecb.europa.eu/explainers/tell-me-more/html/depos...
- pjc50 7y agoPeople who want to buy drugs over the internet, but using their real name facebook account? (No, I don't get it either)
- kerng 7y agoFacebook can't prevent people from using it via fake profiles, etc. that have the intent to bypass things. Unless we want Facebook profiles to always be official profiles (validated via government ID) - which the government would like. France and Germany can entertain IP blocking these services and put laws in place for citizens to not use it. Interestingly though, this is exactly what a free country should not do I guess.
- gjulianm 7y agoUnless a full economy develops under Libra, people will want to convert their Libra to Euros. So you ban the exchanges from operating in your country and force banks to reject any transfers from them. Make using Libra hard enough that most potential users are discouraged, and with low adoption the currency becomes useless. > Interestingly though, this is exactly what a free country should not do I guess. I think a free country should be able to put restrictions in place to avoid foreign profit-driven corporations to interfere and manipulate their economy.
- alacombe 7y agoFrance and Germany are not "the Euro" and IIRC can't decide on their own on EU monetary policies. If they were, we wouldn't be far from the colonial era.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- narrator 7y agoLibra is run by a small group of nodes that have to pay $10 million dollars to get into the consortium. You just fine those companies and seize their assets until they shut down the network or obey the regulations.
- alacombe 7y agoIt's not illegal for a company operating in country X to own assert in country Y which would otherwise be illegal in company X. At worst, company X move its headquarter, delegate ownership to a subsidiary, etc.
- w0de 7y agoYANAL. It certainly could be illegal, depending on the law. For instance, it is illegal for American companies to pay bribes in foreign countries (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Corrupt_Practices_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Corrupt_Practices_Act)
- TazeTSchnitzel 7y agoFinancial rules (e.g. KYC) are very strict and Facebook could be in big trouble with regulators if it knowingly let European users hold currency.
- salawat 7y agoEssentially, the financial network would not allow digital payments out of anything suspected of being a Libra -> local currency exchange, and running any sort of exchange would likely be verboten. In the end, it doesn't really do much but slow things down for some users or add extra steps to the process of extracting value out of Libra as long as somewhere is willing to run a quasi-legal exchange. There is also the option to threaten Facebook/Libra with sanctions if accounts can be proven to have been made/facilitated for Citizens. Another possibility is the requirement to maintain access to the blockchain for mining and analysis against other financial activity the respective governments have the capability to audit. Hence is the danger of something like Libra combined with Nation State scale actors. The common person on it may not see anything but addresses, but given enough out-of-band info, the potential for government use as surveillance (or any large organization really) is far too large.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- hobofan 7y agoIf Libra <=> Euro conversions are made illegal and fined, Libra won't be an option for the usual Facebook user. There might be a "black market" but the few people that would go through a black market are probably not the target audience of the currency.
- mytailorisrich 7y ago> I am not sure how a "black market" could be prevented. Black markets can never be prevented. The question is whether people would want the goods. Is there a black market for Zimbabwean dollars in the USA, for example? Libra is pointless in Europe. In fact, it's pointless anywhere there is a developed financial and payment system. The battleground is therefore places like Africa or South and South East Asia, and there's a reason China has quickly announced an alternative.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoI'm not sure France and Germany fully get what they are trying to ban exactly. Most politicians only have a very rudimentary understanding of this stuff and probably lots of misconceptions. Libra is several things; most of which already exist in other forms in the EU. That makes it hard to block as a whole. At least not without also impacting a lot of other companies and people doing similar things because the law should apply equally to all. First of all, it's a permissive blockchain similar to e.g. Ripple and Stellar, both of which are used by companies in the EU; some of which are fintech companies actively collaborating with the German, French and other governments. Some of the coins on these platforms are stable coins for euros, dollars and other coins. Some of them represent bonds (e.g. a German company called Bitbond) and some of them of them are new coins. Some EU companies even offer credit cards backed by crypto currencies (e.g. Wirex is based in the UK and offers it's products to people in Germany and elsewhere). Then there is the notion that quite a lot of EU citizens own and actively trade in bitcoin, eth, and a wide variety of other coins already. Why would a Libra coin be any different just because Facebook is behind it? The scope of what they can ban here under existing laws seems unclear. Making new laws takes ages and has so far not really happened. Most blockchain companies operate under interpretations of the existing laws. My guess is that market making for Libra like Facebook is planning would probably be subject to regulation and also be problematic in many other countries (like the US). Then there is Move, the language used for implementing smart contracts in Libra. That too already exists in the EU market in the form of loads of companies doing all sorts of things on top of mainly Ethereum and using Solidity, which is technically similar. You can argue about how useful these things are but there is a lot of investment happening in startups doing things with block chains and smart contract. A lot of that is happening with permission of the relevant authorities. E.g Bitbond was approved by the German Bafin. So, singling out Facebook to do any of those things does not sound like it would be very practical from a legal point of view. What they can do is take action if Facebook starts promoting and trading it's own currency within Facebook which I'm guessing would require a bank license or at least expose them to financial regulation. My guess is that Facebook will instead launch Libra with a simple stable coin backed by euros and dollars and post pone launching their own coin. This would make it more similar to what e.g. Apple Pay and Android Pay enable: a simple online wallet that users may use for paying for things online. The fact that there's a blockchain involved is maybe technically interesting but not necessarily a problem. I'm guessing they'll also be exploring using smart contracts for a few things. Facebook as a payment provider would of course be subject to the same kind of rules that Apple, Google, and others have to deal with. A further complication might be that Facebook is isolating Libra into a separate foundation. That might shield them legally and allow them to push some boundaries. One thing they might eventually do is launch Libra the coin only in certain markets. They were talking a lot about third world countries in the original announcement.
- buboard 7y agoLibra is a centralized, cryptocurrency. Facebook will abide by the law and not allow transactions from france & germany with the network.