6 ms·
It's time to talk about post-RMS Free Software
- Jonnax 7y agoOh. I didn't realise Stallman's rigid stance to freedom of software also extended to having sex with children and victims of sex trafficking. It's amazing how much hanging out in the tech world you don't hear anything about this. Of course, just like he argues that a perpetrators is the real victim. I'm sure I'll read some article about how admirable Stallman's views are.
- codr7 7y agoI thought this much would be obvious by now, but here we go. The people who traffic and rape children are mainly found among the filthy rich so called elite. If you want to do something about that, punching RMS won't help. The thing about RMS is that he prefers to use his own brain and is not afraid to stand up for his views, which is an increasingly rare phenomenon. So rare that its nearly considered a crime these days. The perpetrator is a victim, there's no doubt about that. Psychopaths aren't born, they are created through trauma in a society that doesn't give a crap about humans.
- Jonnax 7y agoSo he uses his own brain to advocate for the "elite" and that's somehow admirable.
- codr7 7y agoThat sounds very unlikely to me, and would need to be backed up by solid proof. I think you need to take a chill pill and figure out where all the hate is coming from.
- Jonnax 7y agoSolid proof? The emails he sent to the mailing list is the proof. What hate exactly? It seems there's plenty of people even on this site defending him. Could explain what you're implying that I'm missing?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- new_realist 7y agoOpen source software is driven by powerful economic forces, not by RMS or his politics. In contrast, “free” software is a sideshow. The FSF is mostly irrelevant these days. It’s interesting to note the history of the GNU project, which bootstrapped itself by ripping off pre-existing BSD licensed projects and publishing new implementations as GPL. Open source predates “free” software.
- deanclatworthy 7y agoI grow more and more tired of these discussions. Talks of banishing people because they’re ignorant, rude, sexist. Conferences are getting shut down, people are having their world turned upside down for being ignorant. Every topic is a hot potato. I feel i can’t even have a reasonable conversation about diversity, ignorance, or whatever the controversy of the day is. It’s easier to just be quiet than express opinions.
- pjc50 7y ago> Talks of banishing people because they’re ignorant, rude, sexist. The problem is that not getting those people to stop doing that - or, if necessary, excluding them - causes them to exclude other people.
- interfixus 7y agoWho are the people thus excluded by RMS?
- mikeash 7y agoPeople who aren’t comfortable associating with someone who defends child rape.
- interfixus 7y agoWhich - to the best of my knowledge - Stallman has never defended.
- Jonnax 7y ago“ I am skeptical of the claim that voluntarily [sic] pedophilia harms children.” https://stallman.org/archives/2006-mar-jun.html#05%20June%202006%20%28Dutch%20paedophiles%20form%20political%20party%29 https://stallman.org/archives/2006-mar-jun.html#05%20June%20...
- fouc 7y agoIf you click through to the first to links of the post, it's really quite an eye opener.
- rubbingalcohol 7y ago> Remove everyone, if we must, and let something much better be built from the ashes. This is cancel culture taken to the extreme. Now that everything is built, the builders are expendable. They're "problematic." We're facing down a new form of puritanism that is a greater threat to civil rights than the "problematic" individuals they seek to destroy. No defense for RMS' statement, it's absurd, but if there's no moderation whatsoever in regards to a proportionate response (eg. he's either "clean" or "unclean"), then no one else is safe as the mob ratchets up its criteria for existing as a virtuous person.
- krapp 7y ago>No defense for RMS' statement, it's absurd, but if there's no moderation whatsoever in regards to a proportionate response (eg. he's either "clean" or "unclean"), then no one else is safe as the mob ratchets up it's criteria for existing as a virtuous person. What more proportionate response would you suggest? So far, the only alternative responses I've seen offered are that Stallman is either correct or the true victim, and we should sympathize with him, respect him and let him be.
- rubbingalcohol 7y agoHow about call him an asshole, let him learn from his mistake (or not) and move on?
- krapp 7y agoSo basically, just put up with it and do nothing consequential? RMS isn't some random asshole who made a slightly off-color remark, he's a leader whose influence and cult of personality have shaped the culture around F/OSS development and programming for decades, who appears to have troubling issues around the concept of sex and consent with minors. He's also a man known for his intransigence, so the chances of him "learning his lesson" seem low. To say that he doesn't deserve to be inconvenienced by the social consequences of opinions that would ostracize anyone else isn't proportionate, it's elitist.
- cycloptic 7y agoThe salient point is that free software is a movement consisting of many individuals with their own viewpoints. If you want to support free software without endorsing the behavior of this man then donate your time, money, attention, to a different free software organization. There are a lot of them [0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_free_and_open-source_software_organizations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_free_and_open-source_s...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- xkapastel 7y agoI didn't read this as RMS minimizing sex trafficking or defending rapists. I read it as him making an inappropriate argument about semantics in entirely the wrong place. These are very different things, and it seems like many people, including the author of that Medium article, really want it to be the first instead of the second.
- Jonnax 7y agoHow old is this man? He's not stupid. He knows what he's doing. What a cop out to say "no he was just really hung up about grammar. "
- xkapastel 7y agoNot grammar, the connotations of the phrase "sexual assault". I don't think it's a cop out, I think it's clearly literally the case.
- DanBC 7y agoHe's autistic and he probably has trouble with communication. He might not know that it's a terrible idea to quibble about why his preferred definition of assault is better than the commonly accepted and used definition.
- krapp 7y ago>He's autistic and he probably has trouble with communication. His job is communication. His eloquence, and the precision of his language have been praised more than once here. And autism doesn't come with a "get out of social consequences" card. Certainly not for a sixty year old man.
- DanBC 7y ago> And autism doesn't come with a "get out of social consequences" card. I agree.
- mikeash 7y ago
- Ensorceled 7y agoWhat am I even reading in this thread? > The perpetrator is a victim, there's no doubt about that. Psychopaths aren't born, they are created through trauma in a society that doesn't give a crap about humans. > This is cancel culture taken to the extreme. > I grow more and more tired of these discussions. Talks of banishing people because they’re ignorant, rude, sexist. Stallman is, and has, defending child sex trafficking and rape.
- mikeash 7y agoJesus Christ, HN. I read this article and my reaction was: damn, I knew RMS was weird and opinionated, but I didn’t know he was evil. I come here to see how others react to this revelation and what do I find? “By golly, what is the world coming to when you can’t even defend child rape without someone calling for your removal from leadership?” Y’all motherfuckers need Jesus.
- lidHanteyk 7y agoWho remembers Jimi Hendrix?
- twd99 7y agoit is all about rms being rms. When an act of illegal copying copyrighted material is called piracy, he pedantically says that it is a wrong term, because piracy is a penal crime that involves violence and forcible property theft. when a pimp presents an underage woman to a customer, he pedantically says that it wasn't an assault. I've read the whole email thread and didn't see him defending child rape and sex trafficking. Maybe ones who are quick to condemn him should read something but the medium post
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- zzo38computer 7y agoI think just because someone may be bad at one thing, does not necessarily mean they are bad at other stuff too. Also, I think you should have the right to your opinion. But, people who have other opinion also must have right to their opinion, too, rather than only one. These are just as true with Stallman as with Minsky, and also the other people who complain about it, I think. I don't like it either that they did that sex, and I fail to see how "the most plausible scenario is that she presented herself to him as entirely willing", but I think it make sense that you should not "accusation inflation", even though other people might says differently. I do not defend rapists, but also do not accuse them of other stuff too automatically. Whether or not you use GPL and Emacs and so on are entirely different decisions than those reports they mention, though. It is separate, even if done by the same person.
- shadowgovt 7y agoA useful self-test on this topic is to consider the following question: If we really needed to talk about the inception of ReiserFS, should we bail Reiser out of prison for a bit and pay him a speaker's fee? Or can we content ourselves with considering his technology while excluding the man? It turns out, opinions differ on this. And while I'm not implying that RMS's words are worse than Reiser's actions, I'm noting that the fact some people believe the answer is "Yes, we do bail him out of prison for a bit" is telling on where people in our industry set the bar on dividing a person's works and their other qualities.