3 ms·
I heard a really good argument against high-speed rail in California. We only have so much money to spend on transit. Transit problems tend to be bigger within
by dehrmann 7y ago
I heard a really good argument against high-speed rail in California. We only have so much money to spend on transit. Transit problems tend to be bigger within cities than between them--5 is under-utilized, 880 is over-utilized--so it makes sense to concentrate efforts where we'll get the most return. Projects like a second BART tunnel and Caltrain electrification have a bigger impact on people's lives than a train they occasionally take.
Cabin is an even worse example of HSR demand because it travels when roads are underutilized.
- nickthemagicman 7y agoSee I kind of disagree. High speed train would let people live outside of SF which in turn would ease the pressure on the currently existing city transit.
- ghaff 7y agoHSR would let people spend a number of hours a day commuting to the Bay from Fresno at the cost a few hundred dollars per day. I doubt that would be attractive to all that many people except for those who commute into the Bay area for a chunk of the week and stay in a hotel. But at that point, they could be flying from just about anywhere west of Chicago.
- nickthemagicman 7y agoI think we're thinking of different definitions for a high speed train? There's already a train that connect SF and LA that fits your description.
- throwaway1777 7y agoIt would be too expensive to use for a commute, so I doubt it would let too many people move outside the city.