3 ms·
The medical establishment has long been known to be corrupt or at least suspect - Elsevier was paid to make an entire fake journal so some company could publish
by tomjen3 16y ago
The medical establishment has long been known to be corrupt or at least suspect - Elsevier was paid to make an entire fake journal so some company could publish their "article".
- burgerbrain 16y agoThat some company had to create and entirely new journal just to publish a bogus paper doesn't really seem to support your thesis. If "the medical establishment" were really corrupt, you should be able to just publish your bogus paper in any of the established journals. In fact, your example seems to support the opposite thesis. The medical community in general is rather good at spotting and filtering out corruption.
- cstross 16y agoQuick, a multiple choice exam! Elsevier is best known as being: a) A publishing company who are in the business of selling ink on paper, whose success is evaluated by their shareholders on the basis of their profitability b) A medical research organization who are in the business of pushing back the frontier of human knowledge, whose success is evaluated by their peers on the basis of their replicable research findings Answer: [ a ] (Meta: the point I'm trying to make is that the publishing houses who produce the scholarly journals are not themselves engaged in scientific research. They hold a vital position within the research community, but their actual goal is commercial success. Consequently their goals sometimes become disastrously misaligned with those of their host sector.)
- mturmon 16y agoAnd, to take this a step farther, note that one of the most powerful forces contesting the bad influence of for-profit journals has been the research establishment itself. For instance, most of the board of Kluwer's journal Machine Learning resigned to make an open journal (JMLR, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Journal_of_Machine_Learning_Research http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Journal_of_Machine_Learning_Res...). And NIH now requires free distribution of articles produced under NIH grants, after an embargo period (http://publicaccess.nih.gov/ http://publicaccess.nih.gov/)