3 ms·
> if we don't know what the government is doing, and we aren't going to be told, how are we supposed to hold them accountable? By voting out of office the elec
by pdonis 7y ago
> if we don't know what the government is doing, and we aren't going to be told, how are we supposed to hold them accountable?
By voting out of office the elected officials that allowed us not to be told what was going on.
The members of the intelligence committees in both houses of Congress are cleared for everything. If they are too incompetent to spot, for example, when an agency director is lying to them (as Snowden alleges that James Clapper did), then vote them out and get competent ones in there who can do their homework and spot the lies and call the director on them.
But actually I don't think most of them are that incompetent. I think the idea that all this was happening and no elected representatives knew about it, they all just took the agencies' word that oh, no, perish the thought, of course we wouldn't bend the rules, is ridiculous. The elected representatives knew what was going on and let it happen. If you don't like that, vote them out. The same goes if years go by and no information ever seems to come out about what the agencies are doing, and nobody in Congress seems to have any curiosity about it. Oversight is their job. If they're not doing it, vote them out.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoIt's not that simple. The members of Congress aren't telling you that they aren't doing proper oversight on Clapper. The NSA isn't telling you that they're exceeding their charter (and the Constitution). So how do you know who to start voting out, if you don't know that there's anything going on for which you should be voting people out?
- pdonis 7y ago> how do you know who to start voting out, if you don't know that there's anything going on for which you should be voting people out? Even if you didn't know it before, you know it now (assuming you think that they should be voted out based on what you know now). But really, if you didn't know, or at least suspect, what was going on before, why not? This isn't the first time information has leaked about government agencies doing questionable things. As I said, the government is going to do whatever it takes to protect our security and stop terrorist attacks, because that's what we, through our elected representatives, have told them we want. Once you give the government that job, you can't just sit back and assume all is well. Our form of government depends on the constant vigilance of citizens, particularly when we know we've given the government a job that can't be done under Marquess of Queensberry rules.