3 ms·
In some sense ok. But practically we really need to accept that there are a range of apolitical opinions. There is a massive issue with this proposed alternativ
by roenxi 7y ago
In some sense ok. But practically we really need to accept that there are a range of apolitical opinions. There is a massive issue with this proposed alternative - it is divisive. That line of thinking leads to the classic "with us or against us" style model where one group accepts there is a problem, defines group boundaries then labels everyone not in the group as part of the problem.
If that framing takes hold (and if "can't be apolitical" becomes the dominant philosophy then it will take hold amongst the activists); what is the plan for resolving the issue? Once people are publicly labelled as 'tacitly endorsing' something that they aren't going to be receptive to new ideas.
In terms of actually doing something there is more power in inclusive ideologies where everyone puts their preferences on the table, listens to alternatives and discusses options with people they don't necessarily agree with, and pick a solution that is as fair and reasonable as possible and the people who are disadvantaged accept it on the grounds that they'll get a win next time.
Division is one of a couple of easy paths to conflict. Best to avoid it and let people claim neutrality.