3 ms·
> The actual context that the quote you highlighted was said to point out something different: And I addressed the point the blog post made. Privacy is a diff
by judge2020 7y ago
> The actual context that the quote you highlighted was said to point out something different:
And I addressed the point the blog post made.
Privacy is a different concern compared to confidentiality. The HN title is "Gmail's confidential mode is not confidential", while the blog post only lightly focuses on actual confidentiality (something other email encryption services don't fix either since there are screenshots) and is largely about privacy. Sorry for mistaking what the blog post was going to primarily address based on the HN title.
But, there is a problem with the actual article in terms of what it's saying:
> Gmail as one of the major email services worldwide has realized that privacy concerns are rising constantly - and this is happening at a global scale. To meet this new demand for private and secure emails, Gmail has introduced a new feature: Confidential mode.
Um... no, it was neither created for the purpose of privacy nor security. Nowhere on the support article does it mention the words "private" or "secure", save the actual Privacy Policy footer. Privacy (in terms of Google knowing x and y about me or what's in this email) is not the same as confidentiality (preventing someone from quickly and easily forwarding the email to their friend).
Your privacy concerns are valid in every sense, but attacking confidential mode is effectively clickbait intended to get readers to buy into the encrypted email product and drop Gmail.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]