3 ms·
This article was horrible. Describing the costs/benefits of forgoing college for a trade would be the kind of discussion that I think Hacker News is made for, b
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
This article was horrible. Describing the costs/benefits of forgoing college for a trade would be the kind of discussion that I think Hacker News is made for, but not with this poor quality article.
First, it cherry picks a single example of someone who obviously had a ton of other shit going on (got fired for missing too much work) and then seems to draw from that the conclusion that "Welding won't make you rich". Then it complains that the 150k salaries for welders bandied about are rare, but so what? Did anyone think a welder right out of the gate would make that much money? I think most of us understand that your average developer isn't making 400k a year at Google, either, but that doesn't mean that's an invalid data point.
The reason people should be interested about the trades are:
1. They are immune from offshoring, which has had a huge impact on other blue collar jobs like manufacturing.
2. If they are a viable, and secure, path to the middle class, they should be supported.
There are lots of valid issues to discuss (the toll it takes on your body is a big one), but would be better to see it from an article with better data and less out-of-the-gate bias.
- semi-extrinsic 7y ago> it complains that the 150k salaries for welders bandied about are rare, but so what? Did anyone think a welder right out of the gate would make that much money? If you read it, they say the 90th percentile welder gets paid $60k a year. That is, the average 15+ year experience welder gets paid way less than 50% of the original $150k claim.
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoYour response is exactly why I think the article is horrible - why not lets look at the source data and then discuss that: https://www.bls.gov/ooh/production/welders-cutters-solderers-and-brazers.htm#tab-5 https://www.bls.gov/ooh/production/welders-cutters-solderers... What this says is that the 90th percentile for this entire group of "Welders, Cutters, Solderers and Brazers" was $63,740. But the small table there also says that there is a big difference in the average between "specialty trade contractors" and "manufacturing", which isn't that surprising. It also says nothing about the age range (I don't know where you got your 15+ year experience data from), so when looking at percentiles, it wouldn't be surprising that the field has a ton of junior folks that brings down the average. It would be very interesting to see what the distribution looks like for master welders with at least 10 years experience, but the article has none of that data. Furthermore, if you dig into the 150k claim, you'll see that that is almost always for welders in high demand areas, like oil and gas during the fracking boom. That doesn't make it apocryphal, just constrained to a specific industry.
- Avshalom 7y agoA specific industry for a short period of time.
- rconti 7y agoThe problem is, ultimately, "the trades" are like any other occupation. You can't make $60k a year, let alone $150k a year welding, if you're otherwise making poor decisions. The people doing well at the trades are bright, skilled, conscientious people -- above average at all of those qualities. Just like the 'professionals' doing well with their college degrees.
- maxk42 7y agoYeah, the article starts out describing $150k salaries in Ohio then makes a case study of some guy in the notoriously-poor North Carolina Appalachian region who didn't even become a welder. What kind of piss-poor journalism is that?
- analog31 7y ago>>> 1. They are immune from offshoring, which has had a huge impact on other blue collar jobs like manufacturing. No job is immune from measures that eliminate skilled labor. Consider plumbing. Sure, you need someone to plumb a house. But where my house is plumbed with copper sweat fittings, a contemporary house is plumbed with plastic tubing and swaged fittings that take much less skill and effort. On-site carpentry work is replaced by increasing use of prefab components and things that just snap together. Jobs won't disappear overnight, but there's still a downward pressure on skilled labor content. Prefabrication could easily affect the domestic market for welders. >>> 2. If they are a viable, and secure, path to the middle class, they should be supported. In my view, support labor through better labor laws, and a stronger safety net that includes health care and retirement. Support education. The trades go through boom-bust cycles. The fact that politicians are talking about training more welders could be a signal of the end of a cycle. A career has to last 40 years. Which trades will be in demand in the next decades?