4 ms·
I honestly don't understand, can someone explain? She's literally a child lecturing the grownups. It fits that "emperor has no clothes"/out of the mouths of ba
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
I honestly don't understand, can someone explain?
She's literally a child lecturing the grownups. It fits that "emperor has no clothes"/out of the mouths of babes trope.
The people who back her want to hold her up as someone wise beyond her years. The entire thing is primarily an appeal to emotion.
Greta is the face of the idea that there is a simple and obvious answer that could be readily implemented, if only us sinners would get up off our slothful, gluttonous sorry asses and Do The Right Thing.
Real and viable solutions tend to be more nuanced than that and allow for the complexity of the real world. But arguing against this essentially cute little tribble of a media sensation makes you "obviously stupid" plus a monstrous asshole who clearly kicks puppies as one of your hobbies.
That rankles people who recognize the attempt to win by manipulative social bullshit and thereby simply shut down substantive discussion of a genuine and serious problem that, no, is not going to be resolved by telling 7 billion people to Just Behave!
It doesn't help that the Pope blessed her work, basically. That just doubles down on all the high handed, moralizing preachy nonsense that swirls around her.
- davidivadavid 7y agoThat sounds about right to me. Notwithstanding the pre-existing culture war, using a child to lecture adults just seems like a terrible PR strategy, and to me explains most of the backlash she's getting. I think her net effect will turn out to be negative for her cause. People don't like being talked down to. Is it that hard to understand?
- johnchristopher 7y ago> I think her net effect will turn out to be negative for her cause. It's said people behind her are coming voters. > People don't like being talked down to. Is it that hard to understand? Have you heard how she is being talked down to? It will be remembered view smearing is all they had when confronted with that. It was an opportunity to get things moving, to get people behind a project and they turned it down (again).
- svara 7y ago>She's literally a child lecturing the grownups. It fits that "emperor has no clothes"/out of the mouths of babes trope. >The people who back her want to hold her up as someone wise beyond her years. The entire thing is primarily an appeal to emotion. She's telling a story that directs a lot of attention to an important issue, no more, no less. It sounds to me as if you're criticizing her essentially for telling a compelling story. What standard are you holding her to? She's not a politician, CEO, engineer, etc. ... >Greta is the face of the idea that there is a simple and obvious answer that could be readily implemented, if only us sinners would get up off our slothful, gluttonous sorry asses and Do The Right Thing. Your choice of words, not anyone elses. The fact that this is what her words sound like to you does help answer my original question (where all the hate comes from) though (see atoav's sibling comment...). The rest of your comment is basically saying that she makes a complex issue sound too simple. Maybe so, but claiming that something is "too complex" is often an excuse for not doing anything. In fact, quite a lot could be achieved by measures that are relatively simple. A carbon tax would be a great example. If the publicity she's generated can speed up the introduction of such a tax, she'll have done more for our future than most of the experts she's apparently supposed to defer to.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI've personally paid very little attention to the entire thing. She lost me when she began gallivanting all over the place via plane or whatever to take full advantage of her opportunity to lecture adults on camera and get positive press for doing so. In my mind, her flying all over the world to protest climate policy is in the same category as Leo DiCaprio taking a jet to an award ceremony to recognize him for his environmental activism. I've lived without a car for more than a decade. I walked cross country from Georgia to California and accepted rides while homeless. I took a train out of California to get back into housing elsewhere. I'm an environmental studies major. I don't lecture rich people for taking planes to where they need to be. I also don't make plane trips myself for the express purpose of telling people "You rich assholes need to shrink your god-damned carbon footprint." I abhor hypocrisy. There's not much I hate more than people going "Do as I say, not as I do." I was just trying to take your question at face value and answer it in hopes of being helpful. Otherwise I would have stayed out of this ridiculous theater, which probably would have been the better choice because then I wouldn't be getting ragged on for trying to answer your question.