52 ms·
It would be more expensive for you to hire your own private police force, fire department, sanitation and water treatment plant, and countless other services.
by ineedasername 7y ago
It would be more expensive for you to hire your own private police force, fire department, sanitation and water treatment plant, and countless other services.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoIt actually wouldn't, by a rather large amount, if it meant you could also opt out of the other government services you don't want and which comprise the large majority of the government budget. "We need fire departments and they would cost 30% more if only 70% of people carried fire insurance" is fine until you spend 50,000% of that amount on War in Iraq and buying votes of retirees / drug companies with unsustainably large benefits increases.
- ineedasername 7y agoI don't see the math adding up there, how the average person could have their own mini police and fire force, or any of the countless pieces of infrastructure that we all use. Taking out the portion of our taxes that goes to things we might not want doesn't even begin to cover this. Most of this stuff is available and works at all because everyone pays a little bit and economies of scale kick in to make it less than if each person rolled their own solution.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoYou don't have your own personal fire department, you and thousands of other people who live in your city each pay for fire insurance and the insurance industry then limits their claims by operating a fire company. It's basically the same as what the government does except that you have the option to not pay and then subsequently not have anybody to complain to if your house burns down. And the fire company may show up to put out your house fire anyway (to keep it from spreading) even if you don't have an insurance policy, but then you have a house which is half burnt by fire and half flooded by firefighters and you don't have any insurance, which continues to be a strong incentive to buy fire insurance to begin with and thereby fund the local fire company. In the end you end up in the same place for the services that are actually worth having (like fire departments), because they're worth having so the majority of people buy into them and you still get economies of scale, but you get the option to decline other wasteful services that cost more than they're worth. And that puts useful pressure on individual services to be worth more than they cost.
- ineedasername 7y agoIf you're talking about a bunch of people paying into a fund to cover the cost, then all you've done is reinvent taxes. The only difference is who you pay them to, and that people on the lowest end of the income spectrum can't afford coverage even if they wanted it.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThe only difference is that you have a choice in whether you want to pay the money in exchange for the coverage. Which is exactly the point. The poor don't get out of paying it by having nominally low personal tax rates, because all the other taxes still apply to everyone. When you tax a business and it raises prices or can't give employees higher wages, that comes out of the pockets of the poor the same as everyone else, which is what makes them so poor to begin with. Remove $500 in spending of which $250 were real services, then pay $250 for the real services yourself, and the result is a $250 surplus -- which can go to the poor as much as anyone. They are, after all, the largest beneficiaries of lower unemployment (resulting in more jobs with better wages) and lower prices (because they spend more of their income).