5 ms·
I've noticed over the past year that a Google search for almost any medical term will bury the wikipedia article on the third or fourth page of search results.
by wtallis 7y ago
I've noticed over the past year that a Google search for almost any medical term will bury the wikipedia article on the third or fourth page of search results. The first three pages are all sites with extremely watered-down content and little to none of the cross-referencing links that make wikipedia a good exploratory tool (and a natural fit to PageRank).
Google has obviously decided that anyone searching for a medical term should only be shown pages that are equivalent to what a doctor would tell a scared patient in the first three minutes after delivering a diagnosis. Sure, those WebMD pages are probably going to be a bit more accurate than the wikipedia article, but largely because they're saying much less and have fewer opportunities to be mistaken. It feels rather condescending and patronizing.
- Medicalidiot 7y agoAs someone in medicine, this drive me up the wall. I don't want to go to uptodate every time I have a question and want the basics of a disease or drug. Where Wikipedia fits my requirements perfectly, Google constantly feeds me nonsense WebMD, blogs, and hospital systems. Now, whenever I search for anything medically related I add wiki at the end.
- blackbrokkoli 7y agoSet Duckduckgo as your default search engine and add "!w" anywhere into your search query. This will take you directly to the corresponding wiki article. It is a breeze to actually work with a search engine instead of against it! There are >10k of these bangs, so I'm pretty sure you can even use this tool to directly search at other medicine related sites and portals (check here https://duckduckgo.com/bang https://duckduckgo.com/bang) if necessary .
- lordCarbonFiber 7y agoI feel like more people would have better search experiences if they knew about/used custom search. For example for wikipedia I've got my browsers set up so I can type "wiki <search term> and have that powered by wikipedia; why hit google at all. You can set up the same thing for anything else that implements the open search standard (youtube is the other one i use regularly). To me searching the web for a wiki page seems pretty irrelevant. Instructions for setting up wikipedia's : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Help:Searching_from_a_web_browser https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Help:Searching_from_a_web_brow...
- ser_tyrion 7y agoOr decided to drive traffic to pages with ads from google.
- gumby 7y ago> Sure, those WebMD pages are probably going to be a bit more accurate than the wikipedia article... Not necessarily: https://www.vox.com/2016/4/5/11358268/webmd-accuracy-trustworthy https://www.vox.com/2016/4/5/11358268/webmd-accuracy-trustwo...
- fucking_tragedy 7y ago> The first three pages are all sites with extremely watered-down content and little to none of the cross-referencing links that make wikipedia a good exploratory tool (and a natural fit to PageRank). Those pages are littered with Google ads. It's no wonder that they're prioritized over relevant and information rich results like Wikipedia.