4 ms·
If you want this where you live and people are telling you it costs too much ask them to itemize the cost of the fare gathering machinery, all the accounting an
by anigbrowl 7y ago
If you want this where you live and people are telling you it costs too much ask them to itemize the cost of the fare gathering machinery, all the accounting and cash handling/data processing, the cost of enforcement etc., and then subtract all that from the budget.
Don't listen to any other arguments until they come back with numbers. Oftentimes when you ask a difficult question people try to move onto an easier one, but don't let them. It'll help you grind down the opposition much faster.
- geomark 7y agoTo be fair you must balance it against the costs to administer paying for the "free" service, i.e. cost of collections via taxes or whatever, allocation of resources via some contingent of petty bureaucrats, disbursement via whatever system of adminstrators that are required to keep the books, and enforcement to guard against cronyism, cooking the books and other sorts of corruption.
- snovv_crash 7y agoBut you already have all of that, since public transport is usually subsidized to some degree.
- xwolfi 7y agoOh but you know it all change when a new lump comes in: a new office of collection must be created, temptation to use it to fund something else must be constantly fought, and 2 years later everyone even forgot why this tax was in in the first place. The tax is nice to try, but what's best for laws like that is to remember they are trials, and we should be honest in accepting it's more expensive for everyone to pay a cheap tax than paying more for each transport, however weird it sounds at first.
- lostlogin 7y ago‘Private’ vehicles are subsidised too. You get a a road paved to where you’re going. You get maintenance, bridges, tunnels, intersections, signs, policing, courts, ambulances, fire trucks, lighting, parking (when free). Cars are a massive transfer of public land to private usage. The cost of this needs to be factored in too.
- snovv_crash 7y agoI believe we are in violent agreement.
- zaarn 7y agoYou'll also have to account for the money saved that you no longer have to spend operating the ticket machines or have people patrol the public transports and checking for tickets. That alone should be tens of thousands of euros saved.
- southerntofu 7y agoFrench public transports are already greatly financed by public money. Then, in many regions, employers have to pay a contribution to the transport infrastructure, usually around half the monthly price of their employees' transport bills. Making transports free to end-users actually saves a lot of money by removing all these layers of bureaucracy and control. No need for barriers, repairpeople to fix the ticket machines, and security guards to beat the hell out of people who can't pay.
- xyzzyz 7y agoNot sure how it's going to help you win any argument. Overwhelming majority of cost is wages and benefits of the employees, and right after that it's fleet amortization and fuel costs. Fare gathering costs are minuscule compared to this. See for example breakdown for Seattle bus system: http://metro.kingcounty.gov/am/reports/2014/metro-transit-finances-overview-02-03-14.pdf http://metro.kingcounty.gov/am/reports/2014/metro-transit-fi...
- piffey 7y agoSo that shows fares bring in about $150 million a year. Spread that across the 2 million people living in King County and that's $75 a year for free transit. I feel like that would be a pretty easy sell (considering at $3.25/day for transit you already top that in 30 days regularly) -- especially considering ST3 passed and increased taxes by $300 per year per taxpayer. Edit: Even if you ride the bus only 20 times a year this saves you money. Not to mention it would likely increase usage and stop delays.
- xyzzyz 7y agoIf everyone rode the bus 20 times a year, we'd need much more buses, and the cost would rise correspondingly. Today, with fare at $2.75, and farebox recovery of 27%, the cost averages out to $10/ride. That means that for only 20 times a year, you'd need to raise taxes by $200, not $75. Fortunately, most people don't ever ride a bus, so us Seattle taxpayers who subsidize 73% of the cost of the bus system, have much smaller system to support. If more people used it, the cost would be correspondingly higher. The whole problem here is that it is simply very expensive to run buses, per actual ride. Operational costs of a King County Metro buses is ~$150 an hour. With $2.75 fare, you'd practically need to run them crammed full at all times to break even. In reality, buses only get ever fully packed on a handful of routes, and even then only twice a day. And, ST3 passed, but only barely. I don't think it would have passed today if we got to vote on it again.