3 ms·
I love reading Wolfram essays and wish I could afford Mathematica. This article is from 2017 and Jupyter [0] is from 2014. I wish the article had spent more ti
by prepend 7y ago
I love reading Wolfram essays and wish I could afford Mathematica.
This article is from 2017 and Jupyter [0] is from 2014. I wish the article had spent more time explaining its relationship to jupyter/python/R/etc notebooks. Even though Mathematica has lots of cool proprietary functionality, I think the main benefit of computational essays (what I call a notebook that’s designed for narrative) is not Mathematica but the sort of fact and computation based story.
I like reading articles that include the data and computation behind them. It makes it less likely that they are full of shit, I think.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Jupyter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Jupyter
- AlotOfReading 7y agoMathematica's notebooks were released with v1.0 in 1988 and are the earliest notebook implementation I'm aware of. Jupyter isn't directly related except that they were a spinoff of a project partially inspired by Mathematica, IPython. I've been running Wolfram in my Jupyter environment lately, which is a nice setup to do quick analysis without the hell is Mathematica licensing.
- prepend 7y agoI thought I read something about how notebooks were based on Mathematica, but couldn’t find the article or source. I think it’s fine that wolfram invented it, but it would be more impactful how more common and certainly more approachable techniques could further the computational essay.
- delhanty 7y agoSee this [0] historical retrospective of IPython (the forerunner of Jupyter) in 2012 by its originator Fernando Pérez: >Let's go back to the beginning: when I started IPython in late 2001, I was a graduate student in physics at CU Boulder, and had used extensively first Maple, then Mathematica, both of which have notebook environments. I also used Pascal (earlier) then C/C++, but those two (plus IDL for numerics) were the interactive environments that I knew well, and my experience with them shaped my views on what a good system for everyday scientific computing should look like. In particular, I was a heavy user of the Mathematica notebooks and liked them a lot. [0] http://blog.fperez.org/2012/01/ipython-notebook-historical.html http://blog.fperez.org/2012/01/ipython-notebook-historical.h...
- vbuwivbiu 7y agoSmalltalk's workspaces go back to 1980