3 ms·
>Generally when people ask for a handout from society, society wants to make sure that handout is being used for the things they said it would be used for. Wel
by krapp 7y ago
>Generally when people ask for a handout from society, society wants to make sure that handout is being used for the things they said it would be used for.
Welfare isn't people asking for a handout from society, it's a government program paid for with tax dollars.
Society can complain about having to pay taxes into welfare programs (and often does) but it no more has the right to complain about what recipients do with the money than employers do about their employees.
Also, this becomes a problem in the case of UBI when everyone is getting the handout.
>If you want a blank check that's fine, but you have to be willing to let people starve as a consequence to their actions, with 0 exceptions (from the government) to make it work.
People already starve as a consequence to their actions, sometimes because the restrictions imposed on welfare programs by society make it infeasible for people in need to actually participate in those programs, other times because of bad decisions.
So yeah, I would prefer a blank check, no strings attached, and no moralizing from the crowd that thinks poverty is sin and moral weakness, and that the poor need to be taught a hard lesson before being granted the privilege of a meal.
- tomschlick 7y ago> Welfare isn't people asking for a handout from society, it's a government program paid for with tax dollars. That's the definition of a handout. The government is the people, and giving someone money for nothing in return is a handout. > but it no more has the right to complain about what recipients do with the money than employers do about their employees. That's not comparable at all. With employers there is an exchange of services for money. With welfare there is no exchange. It's meant to help people on hard times, not be a long term income source. > People already starve as a consequence to their actions And I'm arguing the rate would be higher with UBI. > sometimes because the restrictions imposed on welfare programs by society make it infeasible for people in need to actually participate in those programs Which is obviously bad, but those restrictions are because of previous rampant abuse of the system. Without them, the system would likely no longer exist. > no moralizing from the crowd that thinks poverty is sin and moral weakness, and that the poor need to be taught a hard lesson before being granted the privilege of a meal. Yeah I never said that at all. I'm all in favor of helping people for a limited period when they are down, but the system is filled with abuse.