4 ms·
The article covers these points in great detail and spends significant time avoiding exactly what you describe with it's final workaround.
by zamadatix 7y ago
The article covers these points in great detail and spends significant time avoiding exactly what you describe with it's final workaround.
- jvzr 7y agoI know, I read it. But it doesn't work like it says it does. I have Firefox with Windows 10, and the final result ('only styles obtrusive scrollbars') is way too unobtrusive for my tastes. It sorts of look like the Windows 10 scrollbars, but is 1/5th or one quarter the size of a regular scrollbar, and is hidden among the background of the page. Not what I prefer, and what I set up in my OS settings.
- lhorie 7y agoThe core problem, as I see it, is of someone else deciding that "unobtrusive" scrollbars are better. On a mac, to actually grab the scroller for scrubbing, you need to scroll a bit to make it visible and then manage to bring your cursor into a tiny area using the trackpad within a few seconds before the scroller disappears. If you miss, clicking activates window resizing. UIs need to be functional first. Being pretty should never trump being functional.
- IggleSniggle 7y agoOn a Mac, this is configurable. The article talks about this, and about respecting user configuration when possible.
- lhorie 7y ago> configurable I mean, if I write an app and hide a "dysfunctional prettiness [Y/n]" configuration somewhere in settings, is that a good thing? I'd argue there are at least two better options that are trivial to implement, and surely more if one cares to do UX due diligence when trying some novel design.
- mikestew 7y agoI'd argue there are at least two better options... Wasn't your original complaint that someone decided what was "better"? Or are you complaining that they didn't take your choice? Point being that someone that decided otherwise thought they had a good reason for their decision, too. In this case, it could be argued that trackpads reduce the need for the scrollbars. (I have no idea what the real argument for such UI behavior is.)
- lhorie 7y agoI'm talking in generalities. The status quo used to be "scrollbars are visible things". If you're going to change the status quo, it behooves avoiding a dark pattern (like e.g. privacy settings turned off by default). The two better options for UX changes (generally) are to leave it alone, or to create a configuration that defaults to the old way of doing things. You probably heard again and again of some random company doing some major redesign with good intentions and ending up pissing off users. In my experience, the backdrop in many of those cases is that UX changes get rolled out because people need to justify their jobs or they think X is prettier/popular. You don't hear nearly as much about people doing UX research as you do of people cranking out React things, and it would be extremely benevolent to assume developers do in fact do expensive, time consuming UX sessions w/ users. If we talk specifically about scrollbars, maybe a good litmus test is this: - if the default was no scrollbar whatsoever, would that be a problem for you? - if the default was a read-only scrollbar (e.g. it merely reports whereabouts in the page you are, but does not respond to mouse events), would that be a problem for you? If the answer to either of those is "no", you probably aren't actually using it. They could conceivably be configurations too, but why? Consider this hypothetical parallel: why not hide the "Help" menu item in apps? Personally, I don't use it and it would clean up the UI, so it must be fine, right? Well, not necessarily. Because if you bother to do UX sessions w/ users, you may find that people looking to use that specific feature will have expectations about where it should be.
- jacobolus 7y agoPeople changed their interaction after mice and trackpads started to universally include a built-in scroll wheel / scroll gesture. In 1990, everyone scrolled up or down by clicking little buttons at the ends (or at one end) of the scrollbar, or by dragging the scrollbar up and down. By 2019, these buttons are unnecessary and have been removed, and the main purpose of the scrollbar is to passively report the position in the page. Dragging it up and down still works, but few people bother.
- ebg13 7y ago> On a mac, to actually grab the scroller for scrubbing, you need to scroll a bit to make it visible and then manage to bring your cursor into a tiny area using the trackpad This complaint looks disingenuous to me. If you're using a trackpad, you already have scrolling built in and the scrollbar is there primarily for visual feedback. The reason that scrollbars can now be invisible by default is exactly _because_ of the ubiquity of touchpads and mice with built-in scrolling.
- tempguy9999 7y agoYou're (IMO) missing the point. I decide because it my machine. It is not your machine; respect that and everyone will be happy.
- berdon 7y agoThe opposite is true as well - it's the web developers website. If you don't like how they style the scrollbars...don't use it.
- tempguy9999 7y agoInteresting point (upvoted too). Are you a web dev?
- berdon 7y agoNo, and I generally agree with the sentiment that poor UX is bad for the user. I just disagree with users pushing their palate onto others. That's not how it should work.
- tempguy9999 7y agoOoh, that's a bit much. The website dev is pushing their side. No user of the site is forcing anything onto any other user of the site. Perhaps we can have an HTTP header or something that says to the site, please don't mess with browser behaviour. Omit that and the site has got implicit permission.
- nine_k 7y agoBeing pretty helps the first impression in an Apple store, and for first few days. When a user realizes that a scrollbar may be a useful feature, but it's somehow hard to obtain, it's too late to complain, and the Stockholm syndrome kicks in.