The government already has your DNS queries. So the whole point of the argument is moot. The ISPs, and anyone they share the data with, also already have the D

The government already has your DNS queries. So the whole point of the argument is moot. The ISPs, and anyone they share the data with, also already have the DNS queries, so the argument is wrong. But also, if you do want just one government to have the data, do you prefer that data to go to your local country, which may be speech-oppressing regimes like Syria, Saudi Arabia, UK, Ukraine, or Iran? I fail to see how this is in any way a step backwards.