Thanks for your review! It's given me a lot to think about. >3 across list scaling Yes this is a good point. You consider a horizontal scrollbar breaking right

Thanks for your review! It's given me a lot to think about. >3 across list scaling Yes this is a good point. You consider a horizontal scrollbar breaking right? >labels Most of the textfields are 'labeled' with the html5 placeholder tag. You should see some text inside the inputs that gives you instructions. I think that was the wrong thing to do overall and will now be investing in better labels and descriptions. Thanks! >security/permissions Yes, click the edit button on the top of the right sidebar of the list. You'll see all the options there. >notifications Yes right now you get a private message. You're notified by email whenever you get a private message, assuming you've registered a real user. Right now it doesn't have other modes for messaging, but it's probably a good idea to implement those. Might also be a good idea to skip the private message step. >spreadsheet What are the voting options on a google spreadsheet? The primary use of limitedlist is rankings as described on the home page. But I think it's easy to miss. >On LimitedList items are rated in a special way. Each person gets 9 points to distribute throughout all the items in a list. He or she can give only a maximum of 5 points to an item. As a result, each person picks favorites, and has additional power to choose runner ups. We add everyone's ratings together to create a ranked list. If google spreadsheets can do this, then I would say focus and interface. >integration/api Yes totally, so important. I'm working on this. I wonder if it's possible to validate an idea if it's missing such an important part of virality? >useful? well for me, how this started is I wanted to read a new author I just discovered. But he has many books and they're all highly rated. I just wanted to get the *best book, to make sure that I actually like him. It took me a long time to read all the reviews and figure out which book I wanted to read. I think a list would've made things much easier for me. But that's sort of a one off kind of thing. But this can be used for any toplist situation really. I'll be posting some more hacker related lists to HN. >compliments Thanks! thank you so very much. >dmoz not sure about web directory, but it is a slightly different way to organize data.