4 ms·
I strongly disagree. Browsers deal with a hostile environment that poses countless threats to their users, and need to be safe. Arguing that browsers should be
by userbinator 7y ago
I strongly disagree. Browsers deal with a hostile environment that poses countless threats to their users, and need to be safe. Arguing that browsers should be minimal and not protect privacy is like arguing that cars should be minimal and not have seat belts.
I strongly disagree. A browser has one job, and that is to follow and render URLs. Secure connections and such are services provided by other components of the OS, and the browser should absolutely use those services but not attempt to overreach its main purpose. It's really the principle of "do one thing and do it well".
To spin your analogy, you're arguing that cars should have seatbelts that also check your age and blood alcohol level because "that's also a safety thing".
There is an argument that ensuring privacy in DNS could be done outside the browser
Yes, the same way that VPN clients are; and I'm perfectly happy for Mozilla to be working in that area, but most certainly do not put that in the browser and do not make it default.
- Spivak 7y agoWhat do you do as a browser vendor when the OS fails to provide you meaningful security and privacy? This is pretty much how we got here. Basically every device on the planet is right now configured to blindly accept whatever DNS server is handed to it by DHCP and there is really no movement on changing that. So browsers can throw up their hands and say "we are as secure as the OS" or they can do it themselves. Not ideal but the alternative is worse for users.
- userbinator 7y agoWhat do you do as a browser vendor when the OS fails to provide you meaningful security and privacy? Nothing. Absolutely nothing. Work within the environment you're given. Basically every device on the planet is right now configured to blindly accept whatever DNS server is handed to it by DHCP and there is really no movement on changing that. ...and that's just fine, because I trust my LAN more than some third party in another country.
- enraged_camel 7y ago>> It's really the principle of "do one thing and do it well". This sounds good on the surface, but falls apart at the smallest level of logical scrutiny. It's akin to saying, "a car should only accelerate, decelerate and make turns!" After all, that's a car's main purpose. Whereas the fact of the matter is that modern cars are built to be able to handle all kinds of hostile environments and have numerous defense and safety mechanisms in order to keep their passengers safe. The same applies to Internet browsers.
- kmlx 7y ago> I strongly disagree. A browser has one job, and that is to follow and render URLs. wow. not only has history rejected your premise, but the many technologies that exist today in a web browser prove you wrong.