3 ms·
Today I had yet another user complain that our program didn't do the right thing, when in fact it was doing exactly what the user had told it to. The issue see
by magicalhippo 7y ago
Today I had yet another user complain that our program didn't do the right thing, when in fact it was doing exactly what the user had told it to.
The issue seems to be that while this dialog is crystal clear when you read it slowly and understand all the words, most users appear to read what they think it says, and select the dialog option according to that.
It's not a wall of text or anything, it's a medium length sentence on the form "Select Yes to [...], press No if you want [...]". I ran it past the support guys and they thought it was clear as well. But apparently it's very easy to get wrong.
In all cases the users go "oooohhh, that's what it's saying" when they get told to read it carefully, and after that they select the correct option and make the program do what they want.
I spent a fair amount of time figuring out the most clear and correct way to present the choices, but apparently I failed hard... oh well, that dialog is getting rewritten tomorrow!
- rgovostes 7y agoThis is one of the parts of Apple's Human Interface Guidelines that I appreciate the most when I use other operating systems, in particular Windows. > Give alert buttons succinct, logical titles. The best button titles consist of one or two words that describe the result of clicking the button. [...] To the extent possible, use verbs and verb phrases that relate directly to the alert title and message—for example, View All, Reply, or Ignore. Use OK for simple acceptance. Avoid using Yes and No. Suppose opening a document gives me an alert that says, "This document contains macros. Macros may contain viruses that could be harmful to your computer. Do you want to disable macros before opening the file?" With simple Yes/No buttons, I might hastily jump ahead after reading the first sentence and think that affirming the dialog means, "Yes, I know it contains macros." Or I might hastily jump ahead after reading the second sentence and click, "No, I'm scared, don't let this malware infect me." Or I might mistake it for another pop up that happens all the time and also has Yes/No buttons, and not realize until it's too late that I've accidentally enabled macros. Yes, users should read dialogs, but good UI design can help. https://developer.apple.com/design/human-interface-guidelines/macos/windows-and-views/alerts/ https://developer.apple.com/design/human-interface-guideline...