3 ms·
Ask HN: Why are browsers so bad at stopping popups and other dark patterns?
Popups have long been an issue along with other types of ads, but the most infuriating kind I've ever seen are those which watch the mouse position and throw up an ad or subscription plea when I'm moving the mouse upwards to the tab bar after I've finished reading an article and want to close the tab.
Obviously blocking scripts' access to positional data would break many sorts of useful interactions, but there are far more pages that snag that data to display ads on mouseover or page border interactions which brings zero benefit to me as a user. Why is there no way to either pool that information among browser users to negate this dark pattern, or to remember my dismissive interactions of closing popups and pre-emptively negate them next time I visit a page?
Also, if you work as a designer or front-end developer who implements this sort of thing, I want you to feel bad about it and talk your money hungry marketing people out of it; because when your employers' revenue eventually sinks due to pissing off more and more of your readers, you'll get laid off looong before the marketing people do and if you don't stop and think you won't even understand why.
- rolph 7y agoif you use fire fox, i beleive using ctrl + w ; will close the current tab you are on; this apparently is the case with chrome as well. There are 2 solutions here, one is to memorize useful keyboard shortcuts, another is to block the script that watches your mouse movements. Blocking popups may be done but often breaks website and browser function that you want to have.