8 ms·
This seems a positive move for science process, as well as for Elsevier's reputation and the value it can add as a publication venue.
by neilv 7y ago
This seems a positive move for science process, as well as for Elsevier's reputation and the value it can add as a publication venue.
- semi-extrinsic 7y agoI think undoubtedly the reason for "investigating" this now is the optics for Elsevier. They are bad guys in the eyes of most people right now. The main evidence I have for this claim, is that coercive citations are so common as to be a trope in PhD comics and the like. Moreover it is bleeping obvious to the editor, when they receive a review by M. Ister that suggests 10+ new references to M. Ister et al., that this is going on.
- bonoboTP 7y agoIt also de facto deanonymizes the reviewer.