4 ms·
Non-locality is practically axiomatic if you understand Bell's Inequalities, and doesn't require true FTL signalling. MWI doesn't really solve either the local
by TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
Non-locality is practically axiomatic if you understand Bell's Inequalities, and doesn't require true FTL signalling.
MWI doesn't really solve either the locality or the FTL problem. If you're going to believe in MWI you have to explain how an entire universe appears instantaneously, identical in every way to another universe, except for one almost insignificant difference in exactly one quantum interaction.
That's a rather larger and more serious signalling and information transfer problem than the much smaller-scale non-locality required to explain entanglement.
- asfarley 7y agoI don't think MWI claims, exactly, that an entire universe 'appears instantaneously'. Couldn't MWI represented with a probability cloud? Maybe the many-worlds exists as a fixed-volume probability on all states in the universe. From this perspective, MWI would be similar to a multi-universal annealing system, where different quantum outcomes result in fractures within the probability cloud (as opposed to an expansion of the tree-graph).
- platz 7y agoCarroll postulates that all the necessary degrees of freedom are already just sitting there in hilbert space - it's only when the states become orthogonal to each other (e.g. "branching") that we no longer have access to them. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jHLfMXvQqX8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jHLfMXvQqX8
- lmm 7y ago> Non-locality is practically axiomatic if you understand Bell's Inequalities, and doesn't require true FTL signalling. My complaint is exactly that the Copenhagen interpretation introduces that unnecessary FTL signalling requirement. Under the MWI, nothing weird is going on in the EPR thought experiment. But if you believe that a collapse occurs when we measure system A, then that collapse has to somehow occur non-locally and/or be FTL-transmitted between A and B. > If you're going to believe in MWI you have to explain how an entire universe appears instantaneously, identical in every way to another universe, except for one almost insignificant difference in exactly one quantum interaction. You don't; to talk about it in those terms is putting the cart before the horse. You have to believe that a wavefunction evolves in the usual way and represents the thing that it usually represents. You have to believe that when a pure system interacts with a system in superposition then the result is two systems that are entangled and in superposition - something you presumably already believe if you believe in any kind of QM at all. You only have to believe that a new universe appears instantaneously if your interpretation of putting a particle into superposition is that a new particle appears instantaneously, which is not an approach I've ever heard advocated.