7 ms·
I don't see the problem with collecting public profiles. They are, you know, public, and people entered their own data in the interest of propagating it. nonp
by gumby 7y ago
I don't see the problem with collecting public profiles. They are, you know, public, and people entered their own data in the interest of propagating it.
nonpublic profiles (or nonpublic data from public profiles) from, say, FB would be different.
- chmars 7y agoJust four letters: GDPR. And anyway: Just because something is published only does mean that you can collect, store etc. it however you like. That is pretty basic in my opinion.
- banachtarski 7y agoWhat does GDPR have anything to do with the parent post.
- GordonS 7y agoThe parent post explicitly says they don't have a problem with 3rd parties storing personal information hoovered up from LinkedIn. The GDPR is very relevant here - restrictions around the storage and processing of personal information is the whole point of it. While this might seem like a grey area (given the information is public), the GDPR is actually very clear here - you cannot store and process PI without the consent of those individuals.
- hash872 7y agoNot in any way shape or form defending 'Harvesting LinkedIn data'- I think it's quite bad. But I'm getting a little concerned by all these 'but GPDR!' arguments I'm seeing out there. The EU is not a world government, and the GPDR should not apply to non-EU citizens. Europe cannot regulate what I do here in America- the law is not simply applicable. (And I say this as someone that supports more tech company regulation here in the US!) Things like France trying to apply your 'right to be forgotten' to the entire world's Google search results are extremely troubling. Don't apply your country/region's laws to non-citizens, please :)
- toomuchtodo 7y agoGDPR protects the rights of EU residents (vs only citizens). As an American, if I reside in the EU, I am protected by GDPR.
- downandout 7y agoWhile this does not apply to LinkedIn, GDPR does not protect you at all, even if you are a full-fledged EU citizen, on sites that do not intend to serve the EU market. Mere accessibility from the EU is not enough to prove this intent. One could also argue that by having a fine structure that disproportionately affects small businesses (thus consolidating power, money, and personal data in the hands of a few large businesses), GDPR doesn't protect you even on those sites that are subject to it. Some might say that it is actually a privacy killer. But I'll leave that discussion for another day.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- NeedMoreTea 7y ago> a fine structure that disproportionately affects small businesses That's simply untrue. From fines already levied we've seen small businesses getting fines of a few thousands, while BA is getting a fine of a couple of hundred million pounds.
- downandout 7y agoThe facts are not disputable, as they are contained in the plain text of GDPR for everyone to see. The legislation allows for fines of up to 4% of global revenues, or €20 million, whichever is greater. So the “Googles” of the world face fines of no more than 4% of a single year of revenue. Small businesses face potential fines that could be 100,000% (or more) of their annual revenue, because most businesses make far less than €20 million annually. That seems like the very definition of disproportionate to me.
- banachtarski 7y ago> The GDPR is very relevant here If the author of the parent post isn't in Europe, why is it relevant.
- GordonS 7y agoPerhaps I should have been clearer - it's very relevant here, if you are in the EU or do business in the EU.
- tomnipotent 7y ago> and people entered their own data in the interest of propagating it To humans, not machines. No one joined LinkedIn to be marketed to by random jabroni's or to be added to a CRM for BS intro emails that don't have opt out links despite being automated.
- riku_iki 7y agoEmails are not exposed in public profiles..
- Breza 7y agoThat's true to a point. Most workplaces use a standardized format for email addresses. If you have somebody's name, you can send them official looking spam.
- leesalminen 7y agoNice use of jabroni. Did you drink your Fight Milk (tm) today?
- nwalker85 7y agoYeah, we signed up to have that happen inside of the platform, not outside of it.
- prepend 7y agoI don’t think that’s fair to say. I signed up for LinkedIn to publish data to the public that I’m comfortable publishing. I understand that this means random jabronis emailing me and put info out accordingly. I’m not sure how many people feel like me or feel something else. But I don’t think it’s possible to say people post public profiles only for humans to read. I’m really glad my profile gets harvested by google and DDG and have a public email on purpose.