3 ms·
It's very disturbing to see the overreach that Mozilla has resorted to and the "privacy" argument (it was "security" before that...) being used to justify essen
by userbinator 7y ago
It's very disturbing to see the overreach that Mozilla has resorted to and the "privacy" argument (it was "security" before that...) being used to justify essentially ignoring system configuration. My ISP has more accountability than a company in another country.
The correct way would be to standardise DoH and DoT and add support into it into automatic address configurations and operating systems.
Exactly. If Mozilla wants to, it's more than welcome to reach into the VPN area with its own products, but I don't believe this functionality should be part of a browser. They're already reaching into the VPN area[1], should they also investigate bypassing Chinese censorship with their own "firewall-busting" obfuscating VPN? That's not something most users want nor need in their browsers, and such functionality is really a cat-and-mouse game that I think is best left to smaller and less-well-known entities.
It's unfortunate that browsers are already beyond "neutral", when IMHO the only thing they should do is fetch exactly the page URL that was entered and display it.
Edit: yes, apparently people disagree and want Mozilla to control what the Internet (and every user, ignoring his/her default configuration) does. This is really really disturbing.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20927832 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20927832
- seanhunter 7y ago> The correct way would be to standardise DoH and DoT and add support into it into automatic address configurations and operating systems. This is beside the point. Mozilla make a browser. They don't make the address resolution code for the underlying operating system. Operating system vendors are of course going to start to support DNS-over-https. You can disable dns-over-https if you don't want it enabled. Just go to about:config and set network.trr.mode. to 5
- throw0101a 7y ago> You can disable dns-over-https if you don't want it enabled. It was also possible to disable Ubuntu from sending your desktop searches to online retailers: * https://www.pcworld.com/article/2889895/how-to-stop-ubuntu-from-sending-your-desktop-searches-to-online-retailers.html https://www.pcworld.com/article/2889895/how-to-stop-ubuntu-f... Just because something can be disabled does not necessarily mean it should be enabled by default in the first place.
- seanhunter 7y agoThat's a really strange comparison. You know that mozilla has an agreement with cloudflare under which cloudflare has agreed not to log dns queries right?
- Tharkun 7y agoMaybe Mozilla has such an agreement, but I don't. I have a contract with my ISP, and thr GDPR applies to that contract. CF? Not so much.
- seanhunter 7y ago1)Since the agreement is about processing of this data it really doesn't matter whether you have a contract with CF 2)You don't need any contractual relationship to have GDPR apply to processing your data. If you're a European data subject then GDPR applies to any processing of your personally-identifiable data whoever is processing it and wherever they're doing it. If you're not a European data subject then GDPR would only apply if the company was a European company or if the processing was happening in Europe.
- shifto 7y agoThanks. I feel this should just be a setting on the settings screen. I use a PiHole DNS service at home which I want to keep using over this.
- seanhunter 7y agoIt is. I just never use the settings screen. See here for how you toggle it, including screenshots. I would expect that the new version will be similar. https://www.zdnet.com/article/how-to-enable-dns-over-https-doh-in-firefox/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/how-to-enable-dns-over-https-d... Edit: I've just checked and there is the ability in the settings screen to set a custom DoH provider. So once your pihole can do it you can set it there.
- techntoke 7y agoIt should be a setting in a standard dot file. I don't understand why Mozilla can't create a simple configuration file like most applications.
- seanhunter 7y agoAll these settings are stored in ~/.mozilla/firefox/<profile name> So for me the trr mode is stored in /home/sean/.mozilla/firefox/k3dmofx7.default/prefs.js
- techntoke 7y agoI've tried changing prefs from that file and it is a mess. Not adequately documented either. Standard INI-format would be ideal.
- gnode 7y ago> the only thing [browsers] should do is fetch exactly the page URL that was entered and display it. I strongly disagree. Browsers deal with a hostile environment that poses countless threats to their users, and need to be safe. Arguing that browsers should be minimal and not protect privacy is like arguing that cars should be minimal and not have seat belts. There is an argument that ensuring privacy in DNS could be done outside the browser. I think HTTPS is a good precedent for putting privacy in the scope of the browser; the browser should attempt to ensure that privacy expected by the user is established or it should refuse to operate. I disagree with the solution of trusting Cloudflare, but privacy should be considered crucial to user safety in modern browser design decisions.
- userbinator 7y agoI strongly disagree. Browsers deal with a hostile environment that poses countless threats to their users, and need to be safe. Arguing that browsers should be minimal and not protect privacy is like arguing that cars should be minimal and not have seat belts. I strongly disagree. A browser has one job, and that is to follow and render URLs. Secure connections and such are services provided by other components of the OS, and the browser should absolutely use those services but not attempt to overreach its main purpose. It's really the principle of "do one thing and do it well". To spin your analogy, you're arguing that cars should have seatbelts that also check your age and blood alcohol level because "that's also a safety thing". There is an argument that ensuring privacy in DNS could be done outside the browser Yes, the same way that VPN clients are; and I'm perfectly happy for Mozilla to be working in that area, but most certainly do not put that in the browser and do not make it default.
- Spivak 7y agoWhat do you do as a browser vendor when the OS fails to provide you meaningful security and privacy? This is pretty much how we got here. Basically every device on the planet is right now configured to blindly accept whatever DNS server is handed to it by DHCP and there is really no movement on changing that. So browsers can throw up their hands and say "we are as secure as the OS" or they can do it themselves. Not ideal but the alternative is worse for users.