3 ms·
> "Some conservatives (if you didn't know, we're not all the same, we're not all pro-Trump) argue that when government is given a new power, it will use it in w
by mcv 7y ago
> "Some conservatives (if you didn't know, we're not all the same, we're not all pro-Trump) argue that when government is given a new power, it will use it in ways that were unexpected."
And they demonstrate it as soon as they are in power. If a government is determined to abuse its power in ways that were never intended, laws aren't going to stop that. You need elections to stop that. The problem is that people keep voting for politicians who abuse that power and use it in ways that it was never meant for.
> "I hold out hope that the Trump administration serves to the left as a demonstration of the merits of limited government"
It mostly serves as a demonstration of the dangers of governmental overreach, and the dangers of voting for the party that put this government in power.
It's a bit weird to suggest that the party behind it is innocent of their own overreach or abuse of power and blame it all on the laws, when it's the government that makes the laws, executes them, and in this case twists them into the opposite of what they're meant for.
- darkerside 7y ago> The problem is that people keep voting for politicians who abuse that power and use it in ways that it was never meant for. In a democracy, determining what a certain law was "intended for" by all of the various parties who supported its passage is a bit of a false question. When bills are complicated, it's because they serve many masters. So who's intention is the actual intention behind the bill? I think of laws like software for running people. And users always end up using your software on ways you don't expect. Also, if the governing people/party is really intent on abusing power, voting is probably not going to stop it.
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>if the governing people/party is really intent on abusing power, voting is probably not going to stop it. As long as people still believe in the rule of law voting them out will usually get the pendulum swinging the other way.
- vonmoltke 7y ago> The problem is that people keep voting for politicians who abuse that power and use it in ways that it was never meant for. How can we not when all of our options are going to do that, just in different ways?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mcv 7y agoWhat the US really needs is more than two options. The problem is that the first-past-the-post district system ensures you can't really have more than two viable parties. A different electoral system would give voters more options. Sadly, changing the electoral system has to be done by the parties that benefit from the current system, or the voters have to miraculously all decide to vote for the same third-party option.
- vonmoltke 7y agoAbsolutely. It's made worse by the two anointed parties being enshrined in state laws that provide special privileges and benefits to them and their candidates.
- Nasrudith 7y agoThat isn't the sin so much as voting for ones who do again. And even then that has the defense of being a systematic issue resulting from incentives and systems of people. Given an incumbent advantage voting for a known lesser lower abuse of power in spite of professed stance against it may be preferred strategically to the a worse opposition who calls the abuse not far enough (WO or extra bad opposition for short). Primarying them would disadvantage them against the WO in exchange for potential getting someone who actually keeps the promise. A nasty resulting trap in the service of the status quo. The main answer for how not is pressure to reform the electoral system which unfortunately requires a critical mass of support and fervor for an abstract issue.