4 ms·
I appreciate cosmetic improvements as much as the next guy, but my cynical bastard side thinks that cell phones are cheap and ostentatious (because real people
by patio11 16y ago
I appreciate cosmetic improvements as much as the next guy, but my cynical bastard side thinks that cell phones are cheap and ostentatious (because real people actually pay for them) and pension/health benefits that are systematically looting the Californian pocket are expensive and stealthy (because we have convinced ourselves that no one needs to know the cost of these things).
$34 will pay the deferred benefits of, e.g., a California teacher for maybe a few hours if that.
- TomOfTTB 16y agoThis is nice to say and I don't disagree with the sentiment but people need to get real. The unions are the democratic base. No one denies that. A Democrat can't govern without their support and they aren't going to budge on pension/health benefits. So any reform in that area is a non-starter. Even if Jerry Brown wanted to do it there's no way the legislature would support him on it. I'm not attacking him by saying that. I'm stating what I believe is the fact. He can't force the unions to do anything and they aren't going to give ground willingly. So it's simply beyond his power to do no matter how badly he might want to.
- rmk 16y agoYou are right, but I think public opinion is turning steadily against unions: you can see it everywhere, from the rage against teachers' unions in places like Washington D.C., to the disillusionment of private-sector union members with public-sector unions in NJ. People are realising that they have been had, what with our leaders giving away generous benefits to unionised employees during the good times.
- dasht 16y agoThis is Jerry setting a tone familiar to people who look at history. Last time he was governor, he ordered the sale of the Governer's mansion (to this day, governors must provide their own housing). He did not use the state's limo service but, rather, drove himself in a modest car. This time around ... although it his own campaign money, not state money that pays for the inauguration ... he served hot dogs at the inauguration party rather than a fancy meal. These are, in a way, theatrical gestures but they are neither empty gestures or pure pandering to the public. They aren't empty because, for example, saving $20M on the state's cell phone bill won't balance the budget, but it is a hefty chunk of change. They aren't pandering to the public because, as much as anything, the symbolism here is addressed inward on state government. If the governor is doing lots of stuff like this cutting at the top, then on down the hierarchy it becomes potentially embarrassing and career risking for high level civil servants and appointees not to follow in the same spirit. In other words, Jerry's gesture here helps to create a new political weapon: embarrassing someone that is choosing to protect rather than cut dubious perks. (Additionally, this circumstance makes it easier for lower-ranking bosses to cut discretionary perks that they control without invoking a riot among staff.) Finally, this kind of thing is critical armor against the reverse political attack. In this case, for example, the unions can't get in his face and say "How can you expect us to cut salaries or benefits when your own staff and others are wasting state money on stuff like cell phones?"
- patio11 16y agoI will apologize for my lack of faith when he makes meaningful cuts in benefits for unionized state employees, or starts cutting headcount. Let's call it 5% and add the proviso "and cutting future increases doesn't count, and cutting a buck today in return for a buck every week for forever doesn't count."
- dasht 16y agoI don't think you have anything to apologize for. I think your concerns are valid. I was just filling in some detail about what conventional wisdom says Brown is doing with moves like this.
- mootothemax 16y agoSurely when it comes to government-sized budgets, it's about tweaking an old proverb: look after the millions and the billions will look after themselves.