2 ms·
> I think it may be a little naive to say that nuclear can spin up and down by controlling the fuel rods. I'm not sure. Because that's exactly what control rod
by godelski 7y ago
> I think it may be a little naive to say that nuclear can spin up and down by controlling the fuel rods.
I'm not sure. Because that's exactly what control rods do. The carbon is a neutron moderator. Neutrons are the "heat" in the reaction (that creates actual heat). Less neutrons the colder the reaction is. You'll find this in any elementary nuclear or atomic textbook (which I have read).
As for Chernobyl the show actually got a lot right. But there's a lot of important things that get glossed over because it's dramatized. Like the fact that it had a positive void coefficient and no other reactor operates that way because everyone knew it had a chance is blowing up.
Similarly there's a lot wrong with your analysis about three mile and Fukushima. Both of which killed zero people btw. I'd listen to the experts on this one.
- baking 7y agoI don't know what experts you are listening to, but the idea of shutting down a nuclear reactor by lowering the control rods when the sun shines or the wind blows is just plain silly, for economic and safety reasons. Maybe for some future Gen IV design without fuel rods, but what you are talking about would require doubling the staffing and would defeat any cost savings in fuel use. Better to curtail the wind and solar or find ways to store the excess energy in batteries, hydro, or fuel. EDIT: Perhaps you mean something else by "spin up and spin down" but the usual sense of the words implies a complete shut-down. Nuclear reactors do have a normal operating range which can safely be reduced to half-power on a diurnal cycle (typically at night, but could just as easily be during the day.)
- godelski 7y agoNo I mean vary the output levels. Not complete shutdown and restart. That's how the spin up and down phrase was being used in the context of this thread (I had also used the phrase "scale back"). So you and I are in agreement. Edit: you also replied to me twice.
- baking 7y agoHN won't let you edit a comment after a certain amount of time has passed, thus a second reply with the links.
- baking 7y agoHere a some experts you might want to listen to: https://www.quora.com/How-long-does-it-take-to-shut-down-a-nuclear-reactor https://www.quora.com/How-long-does-it-take-to-shut-down-a-n... https://whatisnuclear.com/decay-heat.html https://whatisnuclear.com/decay-heat.html "In risk assessments, loss of decay heat removal accidents are usually the highest-risk scenario to release radiation to the public."