3 ms·
I think what rubs me the wrong way about this site is not the criticism. Criticism is ok. It's lack of proposed solutions. One thing I really enjoy is when des
by bane 16y ago
I think what rubs me the wrong way about this site is not the criticism. Criticism is ok. It's lack of proposed solutions.
One thing I really enjoy is when designers take a look at some established interface and try and design a better one and put it out there for comments and ideas. That is constructive criticism in my book.
example:http://www.flickr.com/photos/zachklein/4831151379/ http://www.flickr.com/photos/zachklein/4831151379/
- lovskogen 16y agoI think the proposed solution to all entries would be "Do it with the HIG in mind".
- bane 16y agoYes, I think I get that, but if everything was done to HIG all apps would look the same (much like all writing conforming to Formal English reads the same). I think what I'm asking is this, what can they do to conform to good GUI guidelines (HIG compliance doesn't necessarily answer that mail) and still maintain a unique looking interface? Also, in many cases, the developer may not know what's wrong with their interface or why it doesn't comply with HIG. Non-constructive criticism like this (while funny on some level) isn't exactly pushing humanity forward, it's just bitching.
- lovskogen 16y agoThese apps are so far from the HIG that pushing this out would make the creators read the HIG, hopefully sucking in some of it.
- dev_jim 16y agoMost of the apps reviewed are beyond salvaging. At least the Delta site had a decent base to work off of.