2 ms·
'Read the Fucking HIG' (and 'Perversion Tracker', two years ago - http://www.perversiontracker.com http://www.perversiontracker.com) is interesting not so much
by gyardley 16y ago
'Read the Fucking HIG' (and 'Perversion Tracker', two years ago - http://www.perversiontracker.com http://www.perversiontracker.com) is interesting not so much for the content of the criticism, but because it's a reaction to the massive influx of new developers into a development community with its own distinct subculture.
Mac developers for the longest time engaged in 'artisanal software production' (for lack of a better term) with high production values - and while a few did well, many of them were just scraping by, doing it largely out of love for the platform. Then iOS came out, everybody learned Objective-C, money began to flow freely, and like homeowners in a town that's suddenly become touristy, they found themselves economically better off but a little ill-at-ease with the new character of their neighborhood.
Because of this, I'm more inclined to give this guy a bit of slack. The criticism isn't personal - it's just one person's way of mourning a world that no longer exists.
- kentosi 16y agoYou've posted perhaps one of the better definitions of this guy's attitude, and I have to agree. However, while he's criticising UI design flaws, he doesn't actually provide any real ideas/examples on how they should fix this. This might just be because he can't afford the time to do so. Ironically, this is probably also the main reason why all these bad designs exist.