3 ms·
I have no evidence, but I suspect most textbooks are written by tenured professors for precisely the reasons you've outlined. I would submit that these people
by pmiller2 16y ago
I have no evidence, but I suspect most textbooks are written by tenured professors for precisely the reasons you've outlined. I would submit that these people (not untenured assistant professors) are the most qualified to write such books. I attribute the fact that most textbooks are terrible to Sturgeon's law (90% of everything is crap), so I don't think changing the incentives will increase the proportion of good textbooks, though it may increase the absolute number of such books.
- jessriedel 16y agoThis is a reasonable suggestion, but I disagree for three reasons: 1. It's a common misconception that professors work very hard for tenure and then, once they get it, are free to do whatever they want. (In other words, that there is some "threshold".) Instead, the system is set up to keep professors on a treadmill until they are very old through grant "carrots". Yes, it's possible once you secure tenure to just hang out and think deep thoughts, but this leads to salary stagnation or even regression. Instead, most professor continually chase money by cranking out research. Taking time off to write books means significantly less salary, (which is not nearly made up for by book royalties). (This is my impression as a physics grad student. Other department might be a bit different.) 2. I claim that the hardest part about writing books is distinguishing what's obvious from what's not for the student. Once you've been using the material for years, it's very difficult to remember all the tiny mental leaps that are required to get from point A to point B. Yes, you need a mastery of the material to write a book, but sufficient mastery for textbook writing comes with only a few years of research experience (as opposed to, say, review papers which require extra experience because they are more-cutting-edge/less-canonical). 3. Even if tenured professors didn't have a penalty for writing textbooks and they were the most qualified (in contradiction to my first two claims) there needs to be some serious incentive for them to get off their ass and write a whole book. Those incentives doesn't exist right now. A lack of penalty isn't enough.