4 ms·
The Fermi Gamma-ray Space telescope orbits at 550 km - I'm not sure how large its Gamma-ray Burst Monitor is, but, it's probably on the order of magnitude of a
by ghshephard 16y ago
The Fermi Gamma-ray Space telescope orbits at 550 km - I'm not sure how large its Gamma-ray Burst Monitor is, but, it's probably on the order of magnitude of a square meter.
From the graph, a TGF creates an additional 80 impacts per microsecond. Under the (admittedly incorrect) presumption that a TGF is omnidirectional, that would suggest a TGF is emitting enough positrons to cause in 10^-6 seconds an increase of 80 impacts on the 1 meter section of the surface of a sphere with a 550 * 10^3 meter radius.
If I don't munge the math, that would suggest each of these TGF is emitting approximately:
4*Pi*(550*10^3 )^2*80 /(1*10^-6 )
3*10^20 positron emissions per TGF that make it to the LEO of the satellite.
Divide as appropriate to account for the likely (per the article) non-omnidirectional nature of the burst (they tend upwards)
Not sure how many are normally absorbed in the atmosphere, or, in fact, if 10^20 is a significant number of positrons - but I'm thinking it would be interesting to mount a TGF detector near, or above, a frequently hit lighting target (Empire State Building gets around 100 Hits per year)
Checking Wikipedia - it turns out that lightning has been a well known source of Gamma Rays for at least 15 years - I read about the observations of the Compton Gamma Ray Observatory in 1994 - and compared it to the more recent discovery by the Fermi Gamma Ray Space telescope. It's hard to see what they discovered that was different this time around.
- gammarator 16y agoWhat's new here is the direct observation of a spectral feature--the well-known 511 keV line--which corresponds to annihilation of the positrons produced by the TGF with electrons. Gamma-rays and electrons had been observed before, but it wasn't known that positrons were produced as well. Compton didn't observe it because its energy resolution was too coarse, and RHESSI (another satellite which has detected many TGFs) doesn't have enough collecting area to do spectroscopy. There are current ground and airborne experiments looking for high energy emission from lightning. (I'm a gamma-ray astrophysicist who works with these satellites on other sources.)
- juiceandjuice 16y agoWhere do you work? I handle the astroserver at SLAC.
- uvdiv 16y agoYou've wrongly assumed that all gamma rays are from positron annihilations. In fact most of them should be from an ordinary EM effect: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bremsstrahlung http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bremsstrahlung The graph in the article is not counting positrons, but gamma photons. A fraction of those photons (not quantified) are from electron-positron annihilations: they infer this because their instrument [1] measures the energy of individual photons, and there is a cluster at/above the lowest possible energy for e-/e+ annihilation photons (511 keV). [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scintillation_counter http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scintillation_counter
- ghshephard 16y agoGiven that this isn't my field, I tried not to make any assumptions. I made my comment based on the following Graph Description: "Each time, positrons in the beam collided with electrons in the spacecraft. The particles annihilated each other, emitting gamma rays detected by Fermi's GBM." I wasn't aware that Gamma Rays were created by anything other than positrons colliding with electrons.