3 ms·
It's interesting to see how Verilog & C both took over there in the industry. There's probably a chasm where the extra typedness isn't worth the velocity cost a
by vlovich123 7y ago
It's interesting to see how Verilog & C both took over there in the industry. There's probably a chasm where the extra typedness isn't worth the velocity cost at the beginning of a project and when it's valuable the weight of switching can be too great. I think the middle ground is a language where you can relax some of your rules but then as pieces mature you can start enforcing stricter typing rules.
I observe the same effect on other things like unit tests except the effect is the reverse of what people typically think. Lots of unit tests early on help you write correct code initially but as code matures it's just wasted automation time & it can end up ossifying some architectural decisions (ie. a change ripples out & causes a large amount of tests to need updating).
- UncleOxidant 7y agoI tend to disagree: strong typing is very valuable in the hardware design space - it's just that you couldn't convince hardware devs of this. If they had exposure to a programming language it was C (and possibly some assembly language) so they wanted something closer to what they were familiar with. When I worked in EDA I was given a project to get rid of linting errors in our generated HDL code. We generated both VHDL and Verilog. Our generated VHDL had very few problems thanks to strong typing. But there were lots of problems to fix in the Verilog code caused by it's weak typing.
- Avamander 7y agoIt's very valuable but not worth acquiring for most developers. I write relatively lot of C, I don't enjoy the familiarity, it just gets the job done for me in 90% less time because the tooling is there, the IDE is there, the documentation and support is good, the libraries are there - it matters a lot in what languages I find tolerable I've noticed. I like PLPGSQL, it's also has all that I've listed, I didn't like Ada and it doesn't have what I listed, because I had to "invent the wheel" so much. In the end, why spend 50-90 % more time to get that last x% of some foggy benefit?
- pjmlp 7y agoVHDL is quite strong across European companies.